Talk:Third Lake, Nova Scotia (disambiguation)

The redirect to Third Lake (Nova Scotia) does not make sense as a SIA is different than a disambiguation page while the SIA complements a disambiguation page WP:SIANOTDAB. Third Lake, Nova Scotia (disambiguation) was probably better as the speedy delete rather than a redirect. The naming scheme for bodies of water is Third Lake (Nova Scotia) to differentiate from settlements. What is the rational that this disambig should be redirected to the SIA? Wolfgang8741 says: If not you, then who? (talk) 13:12, 1 July 2020 (UTC)
 * I initially started a deletion request since the page is empty of content and an empty disambiguation page should not be kept. However, I noticed that the page can be a redirect if the target article can serve the function of a disambiguation page, which I think Third Lake (Nova Scotia) can since it tells us that there are different places that have the same name. See WP:G14 which specifically mentioned that SIA performs a disambiguation-like function. So I decided to redirect it. It's either redirect or delete, and the guidelines suggest it can be kept as a redirect. Hzh (talk) 13:41, 1 July 2020 (UTC)
 * Thanks for explaining, I've been easing into navigating the documenting the SIA vs Disambig for the project because it wasn't clear how WP Lakes were applying them consistently years ago. I agree with the premise and resulting decision now even if the name format technically refers to a difference naming practice norm. Given WP Lakes SIA was somewhat hidden and inactive the state of SIA and Disambig in the project needs review and cleanup where they have been conflated. Current WIP, but we wouldn't mind an assist. Setting up recommendations for a more consistent SIA intro and content to clarify the SIA and differentiate from Disambig to prevent confusion now that class supports SIA for the WP Lakes template as of this week. Cheers.Wolfgang8741 says: If not you, then who? (talk) 14:19, 1 July 2020 (UTC)