Talk:Thunder from Down Under

Wikipedia is a place for fair and useful information. The insulting and personal subjectivity of "Gambal sounds like a poor man's Sting" should not be reprinted on Wikipedia, even if it's a review on AllMusic. The user "Mac Dreamstate" seems to be sticking with the insulting reviews. Such arbitrary editing activities should be excluded. Any review by an editor on AllMusic has nothing to do with Wikipedia. However, there is no need to intentionally republish unfounded and insulting reviews. — Preceding unsigned comment added by CoffeeCartier (talk • contribs) 15:55, 2 November 2019 (UTC)


 * It's not an overwhelmingly negative review. Several tracks are listed as highlights, and three stars out of five is not a bad rating—it's not like it received one star. You're the one being melodramatic and hung up on a throwaway remark about Gambale's singing, as if it constitutes slander or something. Mac Dreamstate (talk) 17:21, 2 November 2019 (UTC)


 * The number of stars does not guarantee the legitimacy of the insult. I don't understand why you make a fetish of that insult review, but your sarcasm towards me also gives you some idea of your purpose. Again, to be clear, the phrase "Gambale sounds like a poor man's Sting" is a blatant insult, and even if it's on AllMusic, it doesn't have to be spread through Wikipedia again. To begin with, the vocals of British Sting and Australian Frank Gambale are not alike, and the expression "Gambal sounds like a poor man's Sting" does not fit the facts. Only facts and useful information are needed for Wikipedia, which is not a place to repost personal insults of AllMusic editors. — Preceding unsigned comment added by CoffeeCartier (talk • contribs) 13:00, 4 November 2019 (UTC)