Talk:Tinkerbells Fairydust

Untitled
First, you only claim the band is important. That may save it from speedy delete, but it can still be deleted via AfD; and without references to establish its notability, it will be deleted that way. It needs some sort of references whatsoever to back up all the claims that are being made, and also references that prove that this band is important in any way whatsoever.

Next, the writing isn't neutral. Don't use phrases like "nice minor-keyed piece". "Nice" is subjective, and therefore automatically NPOV. I know other music articles may use this same wording; too bad, they're all wrong too. &mdash; TheBilly(Talk) 19:30, 15 February 2008 (UTC)

I am baffled. Wikipedia is a comprehensive encyclopedia. A band which has been publicly recorded and sold is surely not completely insignificant. Furthermore #1 in Japan at one point seems to earn the band some recognition, if only of its existence and characteristics.Tallifer1 (talk) 04:36, 15 September 2008 (UTC)