Talk:Toba Tek Singh (short story)

Untitled
I must say this has annoyed me, barely a minute after creating the article, it gets tagged under CSD A7 which states "It is an article about a real person that does not indicate the importance or significance of the subject"

Firstly: it clearly says short *story* therefore cannot be biography of a real person, looking at the plot summary should be instructive.

Secondly: why did it get tagged a minute after creation? I was in the middle of developing the article. It is a stub, I was going to add more details a little later.

Thirdly: have the deletionistas heard of Google? Obviously an article needs to assert its importance - but I had just created this one, a simple google search shows this might indeed be notable.

Fourthly: why are Knock and especially Superiority notable? The latter is rather minimalist, how is it notable?

Fifthly: Whilst writing this it has been deleted, must be part of Wikipedia:Delete Foreign sounding articles with weird names

And finally: I will recreate this article.

Pahari Sahib  07:47, 22 December 2007 (GMT)

Solo Performances by Kamal Pruthi section
You added this section which is totally promotional. There is no reference given for this. Please do not add this again and again. Only add this once you have proper reference. --Spasage (talk) 14:38, 20 April 2018 (UTC)