Talk:Two Fathers (The X-Files)

Various
Cassandra never says that the Samantha Mulder met was a clone, she simply says the woman Mulder met was not Samantha. A minor technicality, yes, but I think we should keep the plot summary as accurate as possible. That series of lines has always bugged the hell out of me because all the adult Samantha clones were killed off in End Game, I don't see how Cassandra even knew about that meeting and I've always felt that best resolution was that it was the real Samantha. Ah well. Not to mention that her line contradicts the episode Closure, although Closure contradicts pretty much every single mythology episode in the series. -_- In any case, regardless off all that, I'd be more comfortable if we simply said what Cassandra actually said in the episode, that she wasn't the real Samantha, and nothing more.

Regardless of how we word the last line of the intro, we should have some sort of reference, what would be best would obviously be some lines for the reception section that discuss how the episode was viewed. Someone's gonna tag it or delete it as OR at some point if we don't have some sort of reference there. I think the best would be a mixture of the old and new language; my experiences and personal opinions anyway are that the two episodes are great, but killing off the Syndicate was a huge mistake that left the mythology rather directionless going forward. Will be gone for a few days, but can revisit this upon my return later during the weekend. Quiddity99 (talk) 13:37, 6 August 2009 (UTC)Quiddity
 * Okay i agree, both with the clone and the destruction of the Syndicate. While i have nothing against the Super Soldier arc, but the Baby William arc kind of destroyed the show. Instead of being a conspiracy show which it was, it became a parody of itself. + To say that the comedy episode were okay, but became kind of boring after a while, season seven was disaster for the Monster-of-the-Week episodes, season eight was a return to old form. But season nine became muddled up in the William arc. But back to basics, we can drop the clones. But it seems like you remember these episodes better than me, so do want you want with the plot summaries.

That "negatively" word, was a mistake by me, changed it to "positvely". I forget stuff during the editing.--TIAYN (talk) 14:29, 6 August 2009 (UTC)