Talk:Union Bay Natural Area

Untitled
Summary: +, cit, so cl, rephrased; see Talk. Explication: See Talk:Seattle, Citing sources.

Suggestion: Rename article to "Union Bay Natural Area" or "Union Bay Marsh" since these are the names by which the famous feature of the area is most widely known, redirecting University Slough. (The UW car park and athletic facilities are more dominant : ) Cf. article. The U. Slough, though the largest of three connected with the lake, is not otherwise navigable or otherwise particularly prominent in the Union Bay Natural Area (UBNA). (Ed. --GoDot 18:52, 3 June 2006 (UTC))


 * Good idea --Lukobe 20:41, 30 May 2006 (UTC)

"Seattle, Washington, USA." Is "USA" essential? Would readers not recognize that Seattle and Washington are in the U.S? WP:MoS recommends linking year only when significant to the article.

Note that J. P. Patches is also widely known throughout Western Washington, lower British Columbia, and is no more fictional than Siegfried & Roy.

noted where needed to distinguish from citation following. Bug with [Wikipedia:Footnotes#Multiple_uses_of_the_same_footnote|multiple uses of the same footnote]] corrected using & command set syntax. (Ed. --GoDot 07:39, 3 July 2006 (UTC))

Does this article qualify for the following additional links?

--64.40.61.112 01:00, 28 May 2006 (UTC)

Thank you for the rename, redirect : )

Summary: + cit, ft wrt cit; see Talk. Explication: Add citations, add short full text (ft) so text would be congruent with respect to (wrt) sources; see Discussion, here below:

Moved reference for location to text describing location.

"University Slough": Citation needed. So far, sources valid per WP:CITE, Wikipedia: # What sources to cite, have none such. Congruent with sources, it is "located at the east of", "Drainage Canal", and three or four "bodies connected with Union Bay". There are ponds of open water also. Three primary sources are cited for the name. Maybe "University Slough" is colloquial, like "The Fill" [Dolan & True] for the area. If so, it would be in print somewhere valid. Similarly, UBNA includss remaining marsh, but it is not itself just a marsh, as the article describes, congruent with citations.

--GoDot 18:52, 3 June 2006 (UTC)

Summary: + cite web, fmt cit, cl. print refs, ft U Slough, +ft history; see Talk. Expansion: Add cite web template. Clean up references to sources having author, page numbers; the complete citation, less page numbers, is in the Bibliography. Add short full text about history. See Disscussion. The proper name for University Slough is Drainage Canal, per sources. See also slough. "[T]he land through which the slough would be cut", thus a canal. --GoDot 07:39, 3 July 2006 (UTC)

Citation format
Would there be any community objections to my doing a simple overhaul of the citations in this article, putting them all into citation templates and fixing the existing templates that are throwing errors?

It seems like the references and bibliography are split between manual APA citation and templates, but the templates aren't compatible with APA because they don't accept "n.d." in the date field. So I think the fastest way to make progress on the cleanup flag is to redo the citation formatting. RiparianCryptid (talk) 07:06, 14 May 2022 (UTC)

While not a good idea for a settled article format, this article needs an update since there are so many errors. Thanks for your efforts in advance. Fettlemap (talk) 15:00, 14 May 2022 (UTC)

So your opinion is that all template citations should be changed to APA instead? RiparianCryptid (talk) 19:37, 14 May 2022 (UTC)