Talk:Uprightness of all Sahaba (Sunni doctrine)

POV
Removed "holy" a few times, changed "Prophet", "The Messenger" and the like to "Muhammad". Still needs to be checked thoroughly to bring article in line with WP:NPOV. ---Benne ['bɛnə] (talk) 20:45, 12 January 2006 (UTC)

Is this an encyclopedia article or is it a podium for the Shia to preach? This article was totally biased against the Sunnis. It lacked all neutrality and was didactic. Why not rename this section to be "Why Sunnis are stupid" section??? As for the Sunni section, whoever wrote that does not know how to use complete sentences.


 * If you are refering to the quotes, its straight from Sunni sites, with source. If you are quoting the "shi'a view" section, it was writen by a anonymous user, and nobody has bothered fixing it. Why dont you? --Striver 11:50, 10 February 2006 (UTC)

I absolutely agree with the first user, but as a Sunni I would hate to change the "Shi'a point of view." The article was EVIDENTLY written to solely support the Shi'a perspective, and while I respect this position, far greater proofs exist for the Sunni viewpoint, however I will leave it to you (whoever authored this article) to be just in the Eyes of Allah (SWT) and to allow this to be reflected. He is definitely a Witness over all things.


 * No, dear brother, i urge you to help with the article. Give all arguements you can find for the Sunni position, and also add the sources for it. Nobody knows all the arguemnts, and nobody but a Sunni knows the Sunni position best. Ma salam. --Striver 20:39, 27 March 2006 (UTC)