Talk:Voith

????
This article seems to list facts and figures taken directly from Voith's corporate website. As for the neutrality of the article, it is difficult to judge one way or the other. On a good faith basis, because the information is from Voith's corporate website - there should be no false or misleading advertising, I'm assuming the article content is factual, there seems nothing controversial. I propose removing the neutrality tag and replacing it with one that asks for references.Surfing bird 06:39, 10 October 2007 (UTC)
 * The sheer listing of the facts and figures in the text was the initial impetus to check the article's neutrality and so I acted upon this and tagged the article appropriately. At the time I guessed it was taken from some corporate source, but I didn't search and compare it to any website. Anyway, if it is taken from a website, the article might have copyright issues, too. Also, the corporate sources usually have some advertisement on their behalf, so at least the biased tone is expected. To cut things short, I don't mind removing the "bias" template, but then all the claims like "Voith Paper is a leading supplier in the international paper industry ..." and "In 1911, Voith built the fastest and widest machine... " should be revised and tagged with  templates accordingly or removed. Much work to do, so it seems. All the best. --Biblbroks 's talk  20:15, 17 October 2007 (UTC)


 * Checked - placed a factcheck tag on one possibly contentious point.
 * The article can be considered neutral in a way, unless there are skeletons in Voith's closet (failed products, scandals etc....)

See below

Merge, suggestions etc
I would suggest a merge of family history and company history sections.. If I was writing this myself - just a suggestion.

Also maybe some images, or perhaps some other method to break up the long text could be considered. eg Timeframe lists, tree diagrams of corporate structure etc.

Otherwise keep up the good work.Carrolljon (talk) 16:48, 15 January 2009 (UTC)

what exactly did the company do between 1933 and 1945?
as with any German company, this oft-forgotten period may not be detailed on the company website but still is part of the company's history — Preceding unsigned comment added by 131.111.184.88 (talk) 21:46, 7 July 2014 (UTC)