Talk:Walt Disney Imagineering/Archive 1

Imagineers aren't Engineers
LittleDan, I agree that the Imagineers aren't engineers, but I removed the edit b/c it didn't flow or add much where you put it (and "basically" was misspelled). I think that saying Imagineering is an R&D group will tell people the same thing. --Zippy 15:22, 20 Aug 2003 (UTC)

Horribly NPOV
''The legacy and the history of the Imagineers is a very rich and complicated one. Ever since the founding of WED Enterprises, when Walt Disney's favorites at the Walt Disney Studios were handpicked to design an immersive themed experience now known as Disneyland, the company has been shrouded in mystery and its secrets are proudly guarded by Disney executives as senior as former CEO Michael Eisner, who had regular meetings with the Imagineers up until a few years before his departure.''
 * I'm having trouble convincing myself this isn't a joke. It sounds like this is written by an Imagineer who is guilty of glorifying the importance of his career, which should not take place in an encyclopedic article. 72.0.105.3 15:44, 22 February 2006 (UTC)
 * Oh, I wish I was an Imagineer. The Imagineers are known for their secrecy in the theme park industry, and I wouldn't argue with the statement that Disneyland is an immersive themed experience. Oh, and the info about Michael Eisner is true as well. I'm sure people would love to think that's my opinion. --Speedway 16:33, 22 February 2006 (UTC)

Funding Section
This section needs a serious reworking as it does not maintain a neutral point of view. Gblaz 19:41, July 19, 2005 (UTC)

Serious Redo
It was very poorly written. And the Funding Section shows them in a bad light which is more of an opinion. Someone please change!

Article Expansion
Walt Disney Imagineering deserves a much bigger article than this. This is an encylopedia, and WDI has such a massive history - it is a very daunting task to take on to document the significant things in WDI's past. Things I suggest we include are; Just a few ideas. I will continue to add to the article. --Speedway 20:52, 16 January 2006 (UTC)
 * The (continuing today) downfall of WDI in the 2000s
 * Just how much influence WDI has in the parks
 * Famous past/present Imagineers
 * Significant milestones passed in technology history, made possible by WDI
 * Collaborations with other R&D companies, such as working with ILM on Star Tours
 * Influence on the Walt Disney Company, e.g. the Imagineering slots on the Disney Channel, WDI techniques being utilised in other areas of Disney
 * Controversies within Imagineering, for example the recent decimation, and things like making Pirates of the Caribbean more PC which upset a lot of Imagineers


 * "Downfall," "influence" and "decimation" inevitably are someone's opinion, however, and sound more than a little melodramatic. Many large U.S. corporations routinely lay off thousands of employees at a time during bleak periods. No matter how unique, WDI isn't immune from the ups and downs of business. Whoville 23:12, 22 January 2006 (UTC)


 * I'll agree with adding more famous Imagineers...what about Christopher Carradine? I can't name anything he did, but he comes from a famous family and (according to other articles I read), he was some sort of VP at some point. Surely that counts for something? (Other than being the odd man out in a family full of actors?) 207.179.115.106 (talk) 04:12, 31 December 2010 (UTC)

Tony Baxter
Tony is currently one of the greatest Imagineers at Disney, and quite possibly one of the greatest ever. He deserves his own Wikipedia page stating any projects he has worked on and what he has done in his career. Would someone please make one.
 * You would create a page on Tony Baxter ? --Gdgourou 08:09, 9 January 2007 (UTC)
 * You could edit the page Tony Baxter (imagineer), i do a disambiguation page on Tony Baxter --Gdgourou 08:15, 9 January 2007 (UTC)