Talk:Walter Irving Scott

Untitled
The article has had it's 'neutrality' challenged. While I understand the need to provide articles in the ways tagged in my recent articles I think it would at least be helpful to have some sort of direction. Each tag says 'refer to talk page' and yet I am constantly having to start the talk page. In other words, posts are being tagged and I am left in the dark as to what has been the issue and what, if anything, needs to be changed.

In regards to the page of Walter Irving Scott it is important to note, for two of the tags (neutrality and sources) that there is only one biographer authorised by Mr.Scott prior to his death. As such, there is only one official record of note on the subject. As such, because the events happened over 80 years ago and no living member of the events is alive, it is the only possible place to find information or descriptions.

I am happy to change whatever needs changing but until I have some concrete reasons, and instructions, I don't see how I can proceed without earning yet another 'tag' of some sort. Thanks, Kalchulainn

Unless some justified responses are forthcoming I think it is only fair I remove the original tags. WIkipedia does have a low tolerance of indiscriminate tagging. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Kalchulainn (talk • contribs) 02:26, 23 March 2011 (UTC)