Talk:Weiyang Palace

Is the figure for the size accurate?
This article states that the size of Weiyang Palace was 4.8 km² (1,200 acres). This figure is cited to a book which judging by its design and vocabulary level appears to be designed for young readers, like of elementary school to early middle school age. I was amazed by this figure, but when I measured the area of the ruins of Han era Chang'an on Google Earth, it gives almost an identical figure. Conversely, the size of the ruins of Weiyang Palace situated within it is far smaller, coming around 100 acres or approx. 0.4 km². Could the author of that book have gotten the size of Han era Chang'an with the size of Weiyang Palace mixed up? Can we find additional sources to verify this? Sol Pacificus (talk) 01:29, 3 January 2021 (UTC)

The article hardly had anything in it.
I could not find what I was looking for and overall the article was way to short. Wikpedia username (talk) 13:45, 30 March 2023 (UTC)

Several Issues
This article has several issues: there are only two sources, a low number for such an important topic; while these sources don't seem explicitly unreliable, neither are peer-reviewed, published articles (for which there are many regarding this topic, either directly or indirectly); the second paragraph of the lead section is completely lifted from the second source; furthermore, the way it is cited leads one to believe that the first sentence is sourced to the first source, which it's not.

I am tempted to insert, and possibly. If no objections are made, I will proceed with the insertion of the first message only, while awaiting further discussion for the insertion of the second.

Eventually I will try to rewrite sections of the article and add more citations.

Dorgondi (talk) 17:56, 21 February 2024 (UTC)