Talk:Windsor T. White

Untitled
Wikipedia: Windsor T. White (1850-1950) developed the White (automobile) Steamer cars, and later trucks, beginning in 1900. These vehicles were known for their quality and performance. White Automobiles provided many vehicles for military service during World War I. After the war, the company became a leading manufacturer of trucks and buses.

Automotive hall of fame: Windsor T. White (1866 - 1958) Beginning in 1900, developed White Steamer cars and trucks that were known for their quality and performance. Provided vehicles for military service during World War I; became a leading manufacturer of trucks and buses after the war.

The same copyvio is duplicated for all three brothers, with the "generic" birth/death date and the same content.

Ori Redler 12:03, 16 July 2006 (UTC)


 * I reviewed the copyvio, and just gave it a re-write rather that deleting. Facts cannot be copyrighted, and there was already a reasonable attempt to make the Wikipedia article different to the quoted website .--Commander Keane 04:45, 8 August 2006 (UTC)


 * Another note, I have redirected the two brother's articles here. Maybe one central article can develop. They are Walter C. White & Rollin H. White--Commander Keane 04:55, 8 August 2006 (UTC)

The article doesn't look like there was an effort to re-write it either before or after the copyvio, as this link and this link clearly show. I am not sure on what your claim for a "reasonable attempt" is based here.

It is true that facts cannot be copyrighted, but the order of facts, the claims, adjectives, and the partially correct (and sometimes entirely wrong) facts -- when coming in the same order as in the original still make it a copyvio. I cannot see any reason to expand this and create a central article, when this is still based on copyvio. It might be better to rely on more extensive sources such as the one here or here. Until that happens, it's still copyvio. Ori Redler 15:05, 13 August 2006 (UTC)


 * True. I have now fully rewritten the article. – Quadell (talk) (bounties) 13:05, 5 September 2006 (UTC)