Talk:Wine Library TV

Did this guy write his own page ?

Issues with this articles
This article has several policy and guideline issues that will need to be corrected. I will give the articles editors about a week's time before I work on correcting them myself. 1.) Reliable sources-Currently this article makes primary reference to what was observed on the video. This steps the line into Original research. What the editors should look for is independent third party verification of the content. 2.) WP:Trivia-Keep in mind we are writing an encyclopedia and the focus should be oriented on the encyclopedic relevance of the topic. This is also where honing in the third party references help since most newspapers, magazines etc will not devote time to such minor details as Vayner-isms or how he feels after the Jets lose, etc. 3.) WP:POV-Sections like Notable Moments cross over the POV line since it is a subjective determination of what is notable or not. 4.) WP:SPAM-Again, keep in mind that we are an encyclopedia and not advertising or promoting these videos. Plugs to get a spreadsheet of ratings on his sites or that hardcore fans can get t-shirts, etc should be removed.
 * I am also going to put up a merge tag since I think the content of this article and the creators page would best be served together. AgneCheese/Wine 19:01, 18 April 2007 (UTC)

Well no one has commented in the 2 weeks since the above post and their article still has serious policy issues. I'm going to be BOLD with the merge and attempt some clean up. AgneCheese/Wine 21:15, 3 May 2007 (UTC)