Talk:World's largest cities by population

Wrong redirect
Changing the redirect to World's largest cities is wrong and misleading. World's largest cities is not "World's largest cities by population". It is a listing by multiple aspects, and doesn't even give a population count. Please do not start another senseless edit war. --BsBsBs (talk) 17:06, 26 July 2010 (UTC)
 * The meaning of "city" is not always clear (i.e. there are multiple ways of delineating a city). Redirecting to the overview article is not misleading. Automatically assuming that "city" = "municipality" is. Please be reasonable. --Polaron | Talk 17:20, 26 July 2010 (UTC)


 * I am asking you to be reasonable and to apply just a little bit of logic. How in the world can "World's largest cities by population" redirect to an article that does not even provide a list of cities by population? To an article that instead deals with the multiple aspects of population counts? To an article that does not provide a single population count? World's largest cities by population did not exist before, and it didn't bug you. In demography, the meaning of "city" is as ambiguous as the meaning of "municipality" - at least on a worldwide scale. The redirect was created because the common civilian often can't even spell "municipality" and doesn't know and doesn't care about the finer nuances between "city" and "municipality". The common civilian will most likely call all entries on that list "cities." And just to make sure, World's largest municipalities by population goes to great pains to explain the finer nuances between "cities" and "municipalities". I think my energies are better used to research and improve articles. If you want to be a serial reverter, fine. But don't allow your brain to be clouded. -- BsBsBs (talk) 17:53, 26 July 2010 (UTC)

PS: The addition to the intro of World's largest municipalities by population is fair and fine by me. -- BsBsBs (talk) 17:59, 26 July 2010 (UTC)

Wrong redirect again
Sorry, I need to ask again: How in the world can "World's largest cities by population" redirect to an article that does not even provide a list of cities by population? To an article that instead deals with the multiple aspects of population counts? To an article that does not provide a single population count? That's World's largest cities -- BsBsBs (talk) 22:34, 3 August 2010 (UTC)