User:ACT1865/Choose an Article

Monica Coleman

The opening paragraph is neutrally written and relevant to the topic.

The section on "Education" contains a list of Coleman's degrees, whereas there could be more of a narrative structure to this section.

There are gaps in this article--there is no "Career" section.

Out of nine materials in the reference list, only one is not by Monica Coleman. This suggests that the claims that are made in this article may need to be expanded to include others' assessments of her work. The citations appear reliable, but there should be more citations outside of Coleman's works.

There is no discussion on the Talk page besides the projects that are connected to this site.

Marcia Y. Riggs

This page has more content that appears to be up to date. The material is neutrally written and relevant.

There information about her career is more extensive, but there are a few other pieces of information that could be included.

The article's claims have citations and they appear reliable.

I did not notice gaps in this article.

There are publications that are missing from the "Writings" section. See Riggs faculty page at Columbia Theological Seminary.

Womanist theology

There is an extensive amount of information in this article.

The most notable problems with this article are that there are key claims that lack citations, and as an editor on the Talk pages names, it is "encyclopedic writing." It needs to be updated and reframed.

The sections on "Etymology" and "Development," are not incorrect, but they could be more robust.

The "Approaches to the Bible" section seems as though it needs more expansive acknowledgement to the approaches of other womanist theologians.

The image of the "female" symbol feels misappropriated on this page.