User:ALTHOYA/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1 (Existing Article)
Title : Ivy + Bean

Evaluation: The Wikipedia article on the children's book series Ivy + Bean provides a basic overview, listing the series' books and mentioning its adaptations. However, it has notable gaps. There is a lack of critical reception and analysis, details on the author's inspiration and writing process, information on the illustrator's contribution, and the impact or legacy of the series on children's literature. Furthermore, the 'Adaptations' section is flagged for expansion, indicating it is incomplete. Details about the development process of the Netflix film, its reception, and further attempts at animated adaptations are absent​.

Sources


 * 1) Google Scholar
 * 2) Google Scholar
 * 3) Gale Literature Resource Center

Option 2 (Existing Article)
Title: Emily Windsnap

Evaluation: The Wikipedia article on Emily Windsnap is relatively brief, with a focus mainly on the series overview and the book list in the main series. It lacks extensive sections on various aspects that could provide a richer understanding of the series. For instance, there is no dedicated section on the reception of the books, which would include critical and public responses, sales figures, or awards. The article also omits information on themes and educational values, which are relevant for children's literature, as well as the influence of the series on its genre. A section on possible adaptations or media renditions, such as films or TV shows, if any exist, is also missing. The article does not elaborate on the development history of the series beyond its origin from a poem, and it could benefit from more information on Liz Kessler's inspirations for subsequent books, as well as details on the publishing history and different editions or translations of the books​.

Sources


 * 1) ProQuest Central
 * 2) ProQuest Central
 * 3) Gale Literature Resource Center

Option 3 (New Article)
Title: Firebird by Misty Copeland

Evaluation: "Firebird" by Misty Copeland meets the basic requirements for notability to be written into a Wikipedia article. It has garnered significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject. Misty Copeland's groundbreaking achievements as a ballerina, especially as the first African-American female principal dancer in the American Ballet Theatre, have received extensive attention from reputable publishers, including newspapers, magazines, and academic journals. "Firebird," in particular, has been a focal point of discussions within the dance community and beyond, showcasing Copeland's unique journey and contributions to the world of ballet. The book has been reviewed and discussed in multiple publications, with its themes of perseverance, diversity, and empowerment resonating with a wide audience. The independent coverage of "Firebird" establishes its notability and warrants its inclusion in a Wikipedia article about Misty Copeland.

Sources


 * 1) Google Scholar
 * 2) Google Scholar
 * 3) Gale Literature Resource Center

Option 4 (New Article)
Title: Babymouse

Evaluation: The Babymouse series meets the basic requirements for notability to be written into a Wikipedia article. It has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject. Created by Jennifer L. Holm and Matthew Holm, the Babymouse series of graphic novels has garnered substantial attention in the field of children's literature, with numerous reviews and discussions in reputable publications, both online and in print. These sources offer in-depth analysis, critiques, and recognition of the series, which follows the adventures of the titular character, a lovable mouse navigating the challenges of childhood and growing up. The independent coverage in reliable sources underscores the series' cultural impact and its significance in the world of children's literature, supporting its eligibility to be its own Wikipedia article.

Sources


 * 1) ProQuest Central
 * 2) Google Scholar
 * 3) Gale Literature Resource Center