User:AVIDBick/Atala (novella)/YL0726 Peer Review

General info

 * Whose work are you reviewing?

AVIDBick


 * Link to draft you're reviewing
 * Link to the current version of the article (if it exists)
 * Atala (novella)
 * Atala (novella)

Evaluate the drafted changes
The existing part of Atala's Wikipedia is very comprehensive in my opinion, but this Wiki article seems to focus only on the original work of Atala. The theme part conveys some of Atala's reflextion on social issues, but the views are relatively limited, and there is only one citation of external references. I think it is doable to add some analysis of the historical background of Atala in this section (or add a new section). Futhermore, generally Wikipedia about novels will have introductions of the main characters, but I did not see them in this Wikipedia-it only summarizes the main plot of the novel. You can try to add an introduction to the main characters before the plot section, such as their identities and personalities, and their relationship with each other. Finally, other piecemeal improvements can also be added, such as the publication details of Atala's various versions and translations.