User:A Fellow Editor/sandbox/Caravan hatnote concerns

Article talkpage threads

 * Talk:Dodge_Caravan#Dab_tags
 * Talk:Nissan_Caravan#Useless_dab_tags
 * RFC on disambiguation hatnotes for 'Caravan' named vehicles

Nissan:

 * 02:57, 6 January 2016 , DAB hatnote in place at least a year+ ago
 * edit summary: NA


 * 13 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes longstanding DAB hatnote
 * edit summary: (these distinguish tags are seriously not necessary.) 


 * 02:01, 14 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin restores hatnote
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 759905683 by Mr.choppers (talk) -- please explain reason for objecting to name disambiguation on talk page) 


 * 18:12, 16 January 2017, User:Regushee switched to a different template (presumably in response to talkpage dialog)
 * edit summary: [no summary]


 * 03:12, 19 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes Regushee's version
 * edit summary: ("see also" tag used incorrectly. Dodge Caravan is unrelated.) 


 * 15:33, 20 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin restores hatnote
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 760823211 by Mr.choppers (talk) -- no consensus on talkpage; 2 of 3 editors discussing the topic support disambiguation) 


 * 16:39, 20 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes hatnote
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 761088881 by Kevjonesin (talk) "See also" tag is absolutely completely erroneous here. It is meant for related things.) 


 * 16:29, 24 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin implements hatnote in a manner comparable to an instance presented on talkpage as an acceptable example by User:Mr.choppers
 * edit summary: (→‎top: applied Template:About disambuation hatnote as per suggestion on talkpage RFC) 


 * 00:42, 25 January 2017, User:Regushee adds wikilink
 * edit summary: [no summary]


 * 09:28, 25 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin modifies phrasing
 * edit summary: (→‎top: streamlined hatnote phrasing) 


 * 09:49, 25 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin adds wikilink
 * edit summary: (→‎top: wikilink) 


 * 09:51, 25 January 2017 , User:Mr.choppers removes hatnote
 * edit summary: (rm senseless tags. No such suggestion was made. Please stop pretending to misread me.) 


 * 10:05, 25 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin restores hatnote
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 761907903 by Mr.choppers (talk) -- an RFC is currently underway as to whether to 'keep' or 'remove'; having something in place to either 'keep' or 'remove' seems self-evident) 


 * 10:30, 25 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes hatnote
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 761909416 by Kevjonesin (talk) Please respond to my concerns. No suggestion to add this tag was made. Adding Cessna is patently absurd.) 


 * , []
 * edit summary:  

~

Dodge:

 * 18:10, 12 January 2016, DAB hatnote already in place (so at least for a year+)


 * 15:05, 13 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes it
 * edit summary: (silly; remove)


 * 01:49, 14 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin undoes removal
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 759905950 by Mr.choppers (talk) -- please elaborate on talk page as to why name disambiguation might be considered 'silly')


 * 18:12, 16 January 2017, User:Regushee changes hatnote template (presumably in response to Mr.choppers having directed his argument at one point to specific choice of hatnote)
 * edit summary: [no summary]


 * 03:12, 19 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes Regushee's version
 * edit summary: (rm tags for unrelated articles)


 * 15:34, 20 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin undoes removal (I appear to have conflated User:Regushee's edit with discussion, oops)
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 760823236 by Mr.choppers (talk) -- no consensus on talkpage; 2 of 3 editors discussing the topic support disambiguation)


 * 16:40, 20 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes hatnote
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 761088974 by Kevjonesin (talk) "See also" tag is used in error. And is not under discussion.)


 * 10:46, 22 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin undoes removal
 * edit summary: (Undid revision 761097730 by Mr.choppers (talk) - perhaps replace with a different DAB hatnote rather than just removing)


 * 09:38, 25 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin adapts with alternate template
 * edit summary: (→‎top: changed dab hatnote as per suggestion on Nissan Caravan RFC)


 * 09:50, 25 January 2017, User:Kevjonesin adds wikilink
 * edit summary: (→‎top: wikilink)


 * 09:52, 25 January 2017, User:Mr.choppers removes hatnote
 * edit summary: (please see talk page)

~