User:Abbymetzger/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title French Gothic architecture - Wikipedia
 * Article Evaluation
 * It stays on topic and gives information on different aspects of French gothic literature. It seems well rounded and has credible sources. On the talk page, there are no critiques on bad work or unreliable sources, they just have additions to the page. The page is neutral and just gives facts without opinion.
 * Sources
 * Gothic Architecture - An Overview of Gothic-Style Architecture (artincontext.org)
 * Sources
 * Gothic Architecture - An Overview of Gothic-Style Architecture (artincontext.org)
 * Gothic Architecture - An Overview of Gothic-Style Architecture (artincontext.org)
 * Gothic Architecture - An Overview of Gothic-Style Architecture (artincontext.org)

Option 2

 * Article title Italian Baroque architecture - Wikipedia
 * Article Evaluation
 * This article needs a bit more work. This will definitely meet the requirements of me adding more information and sources to a page like my projects intends for me to do. It has problem areas in a personal view. It also needs proofreading and more citations for accuracy. This seems like a fairly new page due to the fact nobody has started a talk page.
 * Sources
 * Baroque Architecture - The Decorative Style of 17th-Century Architecture (artincontext.org)
 * Review: Roman Baroque Architecture on JSTOR
 * Baroque Architecture - The Decorative Style of 17th-Century Architecture (artincontext.org)
 * Review: Roman Baroque Architecture on JSTOR

Option 3

 * Article title Ottoman architecture - Wikipedia
 * Article Evaluation
 * This page has a good start but needs revisions. It is rated in the C class. They do have a pretty good list of resources, but some people on the talk page disagree on how credible they are. There are several requests to delete some of the images the author put. There are also some disagreements on how justified some of the facts and dates the author chose. It is a long page, so some heavy research is needed.
 * Sources
 * The Architects of Ottoman Constantinople: The Balyan Family and the History ... - Alyson Wharton - Google Books
 * OTTOMAN ARCHITECTURE (cyberleninka.ru)
 * The Architects of Ottoman Constantinople: The Balyan Family and the History ... - Alyson Wharton - Google Books
 * OTTOMAN ARCHITECTURE (cyberleninka.ru)