User:Acc20/Trimesityliridium(III)/Hienn211 Peer Review

General info
Acc20
 * Whose work are you reviewing?


 * Link to draft you're reviewing:Trimesityliridium
 * Link to the current version of the article (if it exists):Trimesityliridium

Lead
It is brief but concise enough to describe the compound itself. The chembox contains relevant information, which is good.

Synthesis
You may need to introduce what mes is before abbreviating it for rest of page. I also recommend Wiki link for "tetrahydrothiophene" in case readers do not know what it is. Overall, this section includes necessary information introducing how the compound is found, which is good to me.

Reactivity
The description of mechanism and its comparison with osmium are easy to follow. The HOMO image also helps understand your reasoning with molecular orbital analogy. For suggestion, you may have a chemical equation describe one of OAT reactions.

Reference
All citation used in this page are up-to-date and very relevant to the topic. They are all from primary source.

Overall
This article is well-organized and well-written. I did not find any major issues, but minor things that I wrote down above may improve your article. Information is balance, not biased. The images are clear to see. No major grammatical errors are found. The logic is easy to follow. It is nice to read your paper. Good job :)