User:Acs08/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Article on BTS

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I am interested in the topic and would like to learn more.

Evaluate the article
The lead sections are effective in categorizing aspects of the historical and cultural significance of the band. The labels and is easy to navigate. The labels are clear and easy to understand and represent the content clearly

The information is consistent and expansive. There are overlapping topics and themes however they are constant with the information presented, so there are no contradicting information. The information has current and recent events however needs to be edited to reflect scheduled events that have happened, this refers to the Grammy performance that happened yesterday during the Grammys.

Tone and Balance

The tone and balance of this article is written in a neutral tone. There are no biased positions, when there may be opinionated leaning, such as writing in an admiring tone it is cited and in quotations. This allows for reviews and critics notes to be included in a nonbiased manner. The sources are current and there are a variety of them with about 355 cited souses. The articles that are cited are extensive, even when there are random sites cited, there are also reliable articles that are cited for similar points. Link are working properly. Some links are written in Korean, therefore it is harder to determine their reliability and credibility.

Organization and writing quality

The article is written well it is easy to digest and understand. There are no grammatical error and is clear and concise. The article does not drag on with run on

The writing should be clear and professional, the content should be organized sensibly into sections. The article is grammatically correct and has no spelling error.

Images and Media

Some images provide context as to the look and physical changes of the band but do not enhance the understanding of the topic. The images are well captioned. Images are cited there is even a video that is added that is cited. The images are laid out in a pleasing way that do not overwhelm the text.

Talk page discussion

The conversation revolves around correction with dates and references to correct citations with accurate information. This article is rated good, and this article differs as it less likely to get politized.

Overall impressions

This article is overall impressive and an easy understanding the history and relevance and achievements of the band. It is also detailed as there is lots of information and it can get a little over repeated. It can be improved if some information can be consisted further or be referenced if its already written. Overall this is a well developed article.