User:Adji M 13/Evaluate an Article

Evaluate an article

 * Miss Americana
 * I have chosen to evaluate this article because I believe this topic is a very interesting one and I am also a great fan of Taylor Swift. It is an article I understand greatly and have a lot of knowledge about.

Lead evaluation
The lead of this article is not overly detailed nor too vague, it is concise and straight to the point. The article's topic is concisely described in it and an introductory sentence is included. All information given in the lead is present in the article and a table of contents comporting all the article's major sections is included.

Content
Content evaluation

This article deals with Taylor Swift, a female American singer-songwriter who has faced a lot of sexism in her career and thus, discuss it in her movie. The article content is relevant to the topic and up-to-date. However we believe that there is some content relevant to this topic that is missing.

Tone and balance evaluation
From what we have seen, the article is neutral. For example, when talking about the different critics the movie has received, the article has first given an equal amount of positive and negative critics. However, seeing as this movie has received way more positive than negative critics, we believe it was not a perfect balance; therefore it should be changed to portray an accurate representation of the critics given, which was done.

Despite this, the article still remains neutral.

Sources and references evaluation
All the facts in this article are backed up by a reliable source of information and the sources are thorough and current. All the links we have checked worked very fine.

Organization evaluation
We find that the article is well-written and does not contain any grammatical or spelling errors. It is also well organized.

Images and media evaluation
The article does not include many images. However, the images used enhance understanding of the topic. They are also well-captioned and adhere to Wikipedia's copyright regulations. They also chose beautiful images.

Checking the talk page

 * Guiding questions

Talk page evaluation
The conversations in the Talk page were centered around the title of the article, the critical reception and the need to protect the page as new users have been vandalizing it.

The article is part of several WikiProjects such as :


 * WikiProject Taylor Swif t.
 * WikiProject Film / American / Documentary
 * WikiProject Women
 * WikiProject Women in Music

It has been rated as C-class by all and mid-importance by The WikiProject Taylor Swift and WikiProject Women in Music.

The way Wikipedia discusses this topic is pretty accurate from the way wehave talked about it in class.

Overall impressions

 * Guiding questions

Overall evaluation
Overall, the article is good but it is still missing content. It would barely be okay for someone that is just a casually reader. It still contains reliable sources and important content but it would be great if it was more in depth.

Optional activity

 * Choose at least 1 question relevant to the article you're evaluating and leave your evaluation on the article's Talk page. Be sure to sign your feedback

with four tildes — ~


 * Link to feedback: