User:Aidanjmetz/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Voces8

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Voces8 is one of my favorite vocal groups and is one of the best and most commercially successful chamber choirs in the world. I also just saw them in concert over the weekend so they were on my mind. The article, as it stands, is a C-Class article.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section

The lead section of the article is up to par. It is quite concise, but I believe it gives all the necessary information to answer the basic question of "what is voces8?" There is also a nice box section with an image and more information.

Content

The content that exists is mostly quite good. There is an extensive section on the members of Voces8 complete with helpful tables. They have gone out of date very recently however with the addition of a new bass in 2023. There are many sections that, while present, are underdeveloped. The sections for their albums and foundations are lacking, and there is no section for reception.

Tone and Balance

The tone is objective and free of bias. Given the exclusivity and small size of the group, being a member is a major achievement and signals the highest level of choral excellence. Therefore, the members section is quite comprehensive. However, it is not disproportionately large. Rather, other sections are too small.

Sources

The sources used are tricky here, with many of them coming directly from Voces8 themselves. Where possible, it seems the author has used outside sources, but the greater problem here is simply the lack of many outside sources that detail the inner working and initiatives of Voces8.

Organization

The article is clearly organized into clear sections with appropriate headings.

Images

The article is lacking in images. I would appreciate images of each member (or at least current ones) along with images of each album.