User:Aierz/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Gender studies for PAAS 209.

Jackie Chan for PAAS 358.

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
PAAS 209:

I am studying Gender and Marriage in Chinese Popular Media. So I picked the Gender studies' Wiki page.

PAAS 358:

I am studying Screening the Nation. Since this course is about Chinese movie, then I think Jackie Chan's WiKi would work.

Evaluate the article
PAAS 209:

After reading these Wiki, every content is related to the topic. Most of the resources are from the past 30 years. Only a few of them are from the 20s of the 20th century. Overall, the article did a great job. I would think they should remove some of the old quotations.

This WiKi naturally presents everything that does not feel aggressive.

Some quotations are missing the link to the source. However, despite that, each reference is doing its job as a reliable source.

Fascinating talk page, some question how gender studies are only about males and females, and some ask if gender studies are different from female studies. So the rating of this page might be a little bit of a mix of good and bad.

I think this is a great way to discuss a subject.

PAAS 358:

It is a very long Wiki since it is about a person. They show many details about Jackie Chan, and each content tells a different aspect of him. All the resources are up to date, or they can not be outdated since it is about a person that only 67 years old. They need to add more information to these pages as Jackie shoots new movies.

This WiKi is doing a great job of telling Jackie's story; every part feels very friendly.

Every link to the source is also working; all of them are doing a great job supporting the writer's point.

His talk page is shorter than I thought, and most of them complain about this WiKi. So from this talk page, I would say people are not very satisfied with it.