User:Aizaland/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
English poetry

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it is quite interesting how the poetry fashion changed through centuries. It is important because we all have read at least one poetry on the literature class, so we often explore this world. I am impressed by the fast changes in the English poetry styles discussed in the article.

Evaluate the article
Lead section:

-it isn't really concise but gives the general idea of the article so that the reader can understand what it is about.

-no

-no

-it isn't concise but it is also not overly detailed.

Content:

-yes

-yes

-no

-yes

Tone and Balance:

-yes

-no

-no

Sources and References:

-yes but the article needs additional citations for verification

-no

-no

-no

-yes

-yes

Organization and writing quality:

-yes

-I didn't notice any

-yes, it is broken by the timeline

Images and Media:

-the article includes images of some of the writers, so I would say yes

-yes

-yes

-yes

Talk page discussion:

-someone suggest writers who weren't included in the article even though they take an important place in the history of English poetry

-it is highly rated and is a part of two WikiProjects

Overall impressions:

-former featured article

-its content and organization

-to use more sources

-well-developed