User:Ajain1458/sandbox

CE Biographies: William Milnor Roberts
Almost everything in the article is relevant to the topic, and there are no distractions. The article is neutral; there are no claims or frames that appear heavily biased towards a specific point. There are no citations throughout the article. One out of the four citations is linked in the bibliography, and the link does work. The source that is accessible seems like a credible source. Under references, sources include an article from the digital library JSTOR, meeting minutes from the Institute of Civil Engineers, documents from the US Army Corps of Engineers, and a history book. Something that is missing that could be added is more detail about the projects that Roberts has worked on, and his contribution to them. There are two people who contributed to the talk page of the article. The main issue both people mention is the lack of sources and citations.

CE Topics: Body of Knowledge
Almost everything in the article is relevant to the topic, however it is disorganized. The definitions of BOK bulleted do not help with establishing a clear idea of BOK. Also, there is some bias in the article when the author refers to the author of the first bullet point as having a "pragmatic view". The link for the citation of the online source does indeed work, and the source appears to be a credible source. The article does not establish any value of body of knowledge, like its importance and impact. It just lists several definitions of BOK, some of which are hard to comprehend and require further explanation.

CE Subjects: Engineering Economics
Everything in the article is relevant to the topic. There was not anything that was a major distraction. The article is neutral and there are not any claims or frames that are heavily biased. The links for the citations work, and appear as a reliable reference. The sources appear to be unbiased. Something I would recommend would be to include several general equations to mathematically define some key terms.

Good evaluation ...thanks Risk Engineer (talk) 22:47, 8 March 2018 (UTC)