User:Alanl/NPP/Notability/Geographical place

villages/unincorporated communities where no cite is provided
If no good cite can be found immediately, how long should it be allowed to stay?

Possible Consequences of deleting


 * Alienate new editor who might contribute on other articles
 * Accusations of cultural bias/first world centrism

Possible Consequences of keeping
 * Possibility of hoax if good references can't be found, might be newsworthy if discovered later to be fake?


 * No defamation risk
 * Strong possibility that it will never become more a one paragraph article if population does not increase


 * Might disappear, especially in third world countries, refer to discussion on failed proposal


 * Land developers might use wikipedia to deceive buyers that it is bigger/more populated than it really is.

Opinions and discussion

Guideline


 * If GP can be found on google maps and/or reliable cites (such as listing in country census) can be found, then weak keep
 * If GP can't be found google maps or atlas and no cites can be found, then delete

Ono, California
Opinions


 * Very weak delete if it remains as it is. weak keep if cites can be found Alanl (talk) 16:32, 5 October 2012 (UTC)

Shadikongoro
Opinions


 * delete if it remains as it is. weak keep if cites can be found and expanded Alanl (talk) 16:32, 5 October 2012 (UTC)