User:Alanl/NPP/Notability/Sport

= Sport =

Amateur sports league
How big of a geographical area does an amateur sports club need to be?

Port Talbot Football League
Factors to delete
 * no third party cites

Factors to keep
 * debatable per current notability guidelines?
 * assert long history (1926)


 * assert geographic reach (wales)

Opinions


 * Weak Keep if citations can be found. Alanl (talk) 15:24, 5 October 2012 (UTC)

Amateur sports clubs
How big does an amateur club need to be for an article to be kept? What is the harm in deleting vs keeping? Possible Consequences of deleting


 * Alienate new editor who might contribute on other articles


 * Angry email/vandals from fans/members of club

Possible Consequences of keeping
 * Possibility of hoax if good references can't be found, but seems to be not newsworthy if discovered later to be fake


 * Hoard of other similar teams demanding their other team article and subsequent rivalry and other inter-team arguments and vandalism.

Opinions


 * Delete. The benefits don't seem to balance the big downside of increased vandalism and extra load on housekeeping duties. Alanl (talk) 15:19, 5 October 2012 (UTC)

Croeserw Athletic F.C.
Factors to delete
 * no third party cites
 * probably not notable enough per current policies
 * lack of neutral editors to vet changes

Factors to keep

Opinion tag no-ref, can't A7? prod or afd? Alanl (talk) 15:24, 5 October 2012 (UTC)