User:Andrewsaillant/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Alvinocarididae

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
This is one of the deep-sea creature taxa that is an option for the Group Project, and I find these creatures to be quite interesting, however the Wikipedia article is not very in-depth for them.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section: this article has a good lead section, briefly describing what the Alvinocarididae are in the first sentence, and going slightly further into depth in the following sentences about what makes them unique.

Content: this article is somewhat lacking in terms of content. It lists the 7 species of the Alvinocarididae family, however only one of the seven has its own article, while the others just list a variety subspecies and some minor details about them. Content is fairly up to date, with the last update being July 2022.

Tone and Balance: the article is very neutral; there seem to be no inflammatory biases or anything misrepresented, since the article is mostly just a list

Sources and References: there are only 5 cited sources, which is fairly low, however this is a niche topic, and there is not much in the way of research to cite. That said, all citations are from reputable scientific papers.

Organization and Writing Quality: The article is well-written, and has no grammatical errors as far as I can tell, and it is organized effectively.

Images and Media: the article is lacking in this area. It only has two images, one of which is not very effective in enhancing understanding. However, it is important to consider the rarity of really high quality deep-sea photographs which would be really effective in enhancing understanding of the topic.

Talk-page Discussion: there do not seem to be any discussions being had about this page. The article is rated to be in the "Start" stage and of "Low" importance