User:Anthonyhcole/Table

This page is an analysis of all (not just a sample) of User:Makrandjoshi's early IIPM-related edits. It relates to this discussion. --Anthonyhcole (talk · contribs · email) 08:57, 12 February 2015 (UTC)
 * 18 May 2006 First IIPM-related edit - adds info about "IIPM Student Union" to Indian Institute of Planning and Management
 * 18 May 2006 Notes this on the article talk page
 * 18 May 2006 Adds IIPM Student Union info to Indian Institute of Planning and Management advertising and blogging controversy
 * 20 May 2006 Says "I know the people running the site [IIPM Student Union]"
 * 3 June 2006 On IIPM talk page, cites Hindustan Times, Mumbai Edition May 21st 2006, Page 17, saying IIPM's Belgian degree mill is not recognised by the Belgian Education Ministry
 * 3 June 2006 Adds this to the IIPM article
 * 7 June 2006 Removes unsourced puffery from Arindam Chaudhuri
 * 1 August 2006 Trims unsourced puffery from IIPM article
 * 20 September 2006 Restores earlier version of Arindam Chaudhuri, removing a litany of unsourced awards and restoring some less-flattering content.
 * 20 September 2006 Explains on talk page
 * 26 September 2006 Removes poorly-sourced puffery from Arindam Chaudhuri
 * 26 September 2006 Explains on talk page; invites others to restore but with a good source and just the facts.
 * 30 October 2006 Adds "plagiarism controversy" to IIPM article
 * 3 November 2006 Removes from the IIPM article "justification" for the plagiarism (added by Mrinal) that confuses copyright with plagiarism
 * 3 November 2006 Explains on the talk page
 * 3 November 2006 Adds citation
 * 11 November 2006 Removes from IIPM article unsourced claims of affiliation with Stanford, Yale, Wharton, Colombia, etc - claims later repudiated by several of these institutions
 * 11 November 2006 Responds on IIPM talk page to Mrinal's plan to completely rewrite the article
 * 14 November 2006 Asks Mrinal to provide sources for claims about IIPM-Yale and IIPM-Harvard joint ventures, later denied by Yale and Harvard
 * 16 November 2006 Proposes moving a paragraph from "News" section to "Controversy"
 * 25 November 2006 Asks Mrinal for sources. Invites Mrinal to add controversies to Indian Institute of Management (an IIPM competitor)
 * 29 November 2006 Asks Mrinal to cite policy when proposing changes
 * 30 November 2006 Asks Mrinal to cite policy when proposing changes
 * 15:40, 22 December 2006 Restores IIPM article to earlier version after controversies section was deleted
 * 22 December 2006 Asks Mrinal to cite policy when proposing changes and discuss before removing content that has talk page consensus.
 * 26 December 2006 Responds on the IIPM talk page to
 * Iipmstudent9's critique of JAM and its editor
 * Mrinal's attack on two editors
 * Iipmstudent9's proposal to gut the controversy section


 * 27 December 2006 Reverts Iipmstudent9's changes to IIPM article including:
 * her addition of "possibly the world's largest business school" (citing a source that says "[IIPM] now claims to be the world’s largest business school")
 * her removal of "IMI, Belgium grants BBA and MBA degrees to students of IIPM. However, the Ministry of Education Belgium ... clarified that IMI is not recognised as a business school in Belgium, and its degrees are not treated as equivalent to recognised BBA and MBA degrees."
 * her unsourced addition of "IIPM faculty conduct Executive Education programs, some of which are in collaboration with faculty from Harvard, Stanford, Wharton, INSEAD and other business schools"
 * her gutting of the controversy section


 * 27 December 2006 Discusses the above
 * 27 December 2006 Restores unbiased content added by Iipmstudent9
 * 27 December 2006 Adds to IIPM article "In December 2006, the AICTE issued a notice to 77 management institutes, including IIPM, citing the 1987 AICTE Act."
 * 28 December 2006 Restores content to IIPM article deleted by Iipmstudent9: "IMI, Belgium grants BBA and MBA degrees to students of IIPM. However, the Ministry of Education Belgium ... clarified that IMI is not recognised as a business school in Belgium, and its degrees are not treated as equivalent to recognised BBA and MBA degrees."
 * 28 December 2006 Discusses the above
 * 28 December 2006 Adds "unaccredited" to "IMI Belgium" (Chaudhuri's Belgian degree mill) in the IIPM article. Cites UGC chaiman saying IIPM cannot offer an MBA degree since it violates the University Grants Commission Act of 1956, and cites UGC chairman calling IIPM's use of fine print in its advertisements "misleading"