User:AntiMemo/sandbox

ASU HST 304 class assignment

 Article Evaluation: 1939–40 Winter Offensive 

-Engagement between China and Japan during Second Sino-Japanese War

-Name doesn't imply which side made the offensive

-Name vague overall, would have initially assumed part of WWII based on dates

-Explains situations prior which helped lead to offensive

-Explains results and aftermath, and how it impacted the rest of the war

Content

-Relevant and article appears up to date

Tone

-Neutral-ish, a little more attention given to China but they are the ones who mounted the offensive so it's fair

Sources

-Checked over 10 linked sources, they all work and are up to date

-A lot of sources in Chinese and some from a Chinese newspaper during the war, so it could be a little biased, but article seems fair overall

Talk

-No ongoing conversations, last updated in 2017