User:Anyssa.pat/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
"Medical device"

"Healthcare in the United States"

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
The article "Medical device" provides a holistic review on medical devices, providing a foundation for discussion to build upon. The structure and the content of the article grant a general understanding, and enough information for debates amongst conversations arising concerning medical equipment and devices, from history to regulation, from designs to being used as a resource. When there is a foundation for these discussions, then there is stability and a degree of agreement in which debates can begin off on in order to find a solution for exchanges that involve medical equipment, such as the donation of the equipment due to different circumstances and intentions. The first impression was rather simple, for the facts were solely written out, however the facts are able to structurally complement each other to create an article useful for the debates surrounding donations and the lack of accessibility to medical devices in certain communities.

The article "Healthcare in the United States" stores and showcases information to completely evaluate the topic of healthcare within the United States in its entirety, providing information regarding its history, the participants within the industry, the activity and regulation, a critique on the effectiveness of the system, and debates concerning the industry. The article offers itself as a starting point for conversations and debates concerning the healthcare industry, and is structured in a manner that is useful for understanding debates surrounding donations and the lack of accessibility to medical devices in certain communities. The article is nicely structured so the audience is able to simply navigate from foundation to conversation.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section

The article fails to begin with a hook, or a line that encapsulates the audience into reading the article, and merely defines what a medical device is. The lead section solely focuses on the factual and statistically supported information about medical devices, but successfully introduces each section of the article with a short introduction statement about the history, their current use, and their future use. The lead section of this article is rather concise, than detailed.

The article begins with a very specific comment towards the spending and economics of healthcare in the United States, and fails to encompass the content within the article in its entirety. The lead section is lengthy, but doesn't provide much context about the debates and conversations that will be discussed within the article, and focuses on the statistical analysis of the industry's spending and a short historical analysis of the industry.

Content

The content needs to be updated, and there is an alert that reminds the readers that the article has yet to be updated. Sections discussing the E.U. and derivative and implantable medical devices are out-of-date, and the last time the article was updated was April 2022. There are sections that lake citations, and the entirety of the history section does not exist, even though the article sprinkles historical information throughout the article. There are sections that are duplicated, and lack the appropriate amount of citations needed for verification.

Some of the content cited and added in the article needs to be updated, and there are alerts for contradictions by topics covered within the article itself. The "History" section of the article is concise and short, and doesn't necessarily speak on the history of the healthcare in the United States.

Tone and Balance

Overall, the article remains rather neutral throughout its entirety, which becomes a perfect foundation to allow individuals to perceive the information with their own thoughts and opinions. The article offers solely information, and factual information that is structured in an informational and educational manner.

The tone of the article remains neutral, and takes a position that provides information rather than appearing argumentative. The article works as a foundation for individuals to create their own thoughts and opinions, and for the audience to have statistical and supported evidence for their thoughts.

Sources and References

The sources used to cite the information used in the article are diverse in style and type of paper, ranging from research to secondary articles depending on the type of information requested and needed. The sources are thorough, but not the most up-to-date articles that could be used.

Organization and Writing Quality

The article lacks grammatical errors, and is concise enough to understand and read. There are also multiple sector titles that allow the article to operate and be read in a smooth manner.

Images and MediaThere are multiple images to emphasize medical devices and how they are used in medical circumstances and atmospheres, but there are no photos outside of that scope of practice.The images are also placed in a way where it is visually pleasing, and still understandable.

Talk Page discussion

Based on the articles, most of the discussion can be notably focused on medical equipment donations, the spread of medical access, and short-term and long-term solutions for the issues.