User:Ashleighann24/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1
Election security

Article Evaluation

 * The article content is relevant to the topic and written neutrally.
 * Not all claims have references, but the large majority do.
 * There are a fair number of reliable references.
 * The article looks at election fraud, which is a subject that has been largely misrepresented and politicized over the past several years. It tackles the subject neutrally.
 * The talk page alerts on a contributor with a conflict of interest and a history of plagiarism issues.
 * The issue is high importance in several areas
 * I would look at discussing election security in upcoming election

Option 2
Hacktivism

Article Evaluation

 * Introduction discusses and aligns to sub sections.
 * Multiple citations are missing.
 * Unsupported attributions noted throughout the article.
 * Content is relevant and mostly neutral.
 * Notable hacktivist events have not been updated since 2022. There have been events worth noting that could be discussed in this section.
 * There were concerns regarding organization of the article, specifically the placement of controversial events before methods. Editor suggested this put an emphasis over controversy vs defining Hacktivism.

Option 3
Cyberethics

Article Evaluation

 * Missing citations
 * Lead needs a lot of work and should discuss (at a high level) what is touched on in the article.
 * The organization of the article leaves a lot to be desired. There's a large focus on privacy and data collection.
 * Not sure all sections and content is within scope. Believe the article goes beyond defining Cyberethics.
 * Delves a great deal into privacy concerns, believe this may be appropriate for a separate article.
 * Some citations missing.
 * References appear reliable.
 * Talk page mirrors the concerns regarding structure and focus of wiki article.