User:Bagumba/XfDs

Articles for deletion/José Casilla - a non-notable minor league baseball player that didnt need to wait until end of career to delete per WP:CRYSTAL

Templates_for_discussion/Log/2012_May_20 - navbox and inconsistent application of "articles should refer to each other, to a reasonable extent"

Articles for deletion/Stelios Ioannou‎ - kept due to WP:NBASKETBALL application of "or a similar major professional sports league" for Greek Basket League

Articles for deletion/List of National Basketball Association season minutes leaders Stats list kept with minimal demonstration of WP:LISTN.

Articles for deletion/Jabari Parker's high school career article that meets GNG but consensus was not to split

Articles for deletion/2013 Maria Sharapova tennis season player is notable but this season article was not.

Articles for deletion/Alfredo Gonzalez (baseball) player called up to MLB but never played a game, deleted for lack of significant coverage

Articles for deletion/Kenneth Walker III, NFL training camp cut of average college player who received coverage in large LA market in college. No consensus

Articles for deletion/Big Three (Cleveland Cavaliers), lots of coverage on grouping but term is overused and considered not notable

Articles for deletion/Jordan Baker (basketball) deleted after "similar league" loophole was removed

Articles for deletion/Rocket Watts, kept high school player that met GNG but not NHOOPS

Articles for deletion/List of career achievements by Brett Favre, deletion of multiple NFL career achievement pages
 * Articles for deletion/List of career achievements by Dwyane Wade (2nd nomination)
 * Articles for deletion/List of career achievements by Chris Paul

Articles for deletion/Mikey Williams, del 15-year-old HS basketball player meets GNG but not WP:SUSTAINED

Meets SNG but
Articles for deletion/Smith (baseball) Met NSPORTS but failed GNG

Articles for deletion/Pete Vainowski Deleted: 2:1 majority that met NGRIDIRON over GNG

Deletion_review/Log/2022_January_19 Meets NFOOTY, deleted said GNG wasn't met, DRV consensus to uphold keep

Articles for deletion/Rit Harrison Deleted, met WP:NBASE, but only keep vote was contested for non-providing reliable source (baseball-reference.con could have been, but was not, cited)

Articles_for_deletion/John_Dwyer_(baseball) Meets NBASE, no consensus

No consensus
Articles for deletion/Mike Basso‎‎

Templates_for_discussion/Log/2011_November_30 navbox that navigates to other navboxes

Articles for deletion/Simon Reed dab page full of MOS:DABMENTIONs

Tfd
Templates_for_discussion/Log/2011_November_5 nav footer to other roster navs

Non-English source caveat
Granted, I might not find these on English websites, and also wouldn't know which ones are reliable. This is the difficulty with dealing with potentially notable subjects covered in predominantly non-English sources. However, no persuasive arguments have been forthcoming either.

Red link navs with no article

 * Delete Fails WP:EXISTING with only one blue link. Fails  WP:NAVBOX No. 4: "There should be a Wikipedia article on the subject of the template." A standalone list that meets WP:LISTN is needed to establish notability of this grouping.  Existence of navboxes like this just encourages others to copy and create more non-notable ones.

Navs with no article
Delete: Fails WP:NAVBOX No. 4: "There should be a Wikipedia article on the subject of the template." At a minimum, whether the article is immediately created or not, the list should be demonstrated to meet WP:LISTN, which would require independent coverage and rule out affiliated organizations as a source. Even if the page is created, I'm more of the thinking that a reader can generally click through to the link in the article if they want to see the other members. Projects WikiProjects need to develop more internal guidance on being more selective to avoid template creep

Non-medaling national team navboxes
Delete all per WP:TCREEP. Teams that do not earn a medal do not need the Wikipedia equivalent of a participation trophy. Also consistent with prior TfDs such as Templates_for_discussion/Log/2016_December_29.

Non-notable league's championship navboxes
Templates_for_discussion/Log/2018_August_24

Rivalries
Fails WP:GNG with lack of significant coverage in multiple, independent sources. The biggest issue is that it fails the guideline WP:WHYN, namely that multiple sources are needed "so that we can write a fair and balanced article that complies with Wikipedia's neutral point of view policy ..." Otherwise, editors will just cherry-pick facts from routine coverage in recaps of individual games, as opposed to independent sources that look at the rivalry as a whole. Moreover, routine coverage liberally uses the term rivalry to manufacture hype. At this point, it looks like calling this a "rivalry" is WP:OR.

WHYN
Per WP:WHYN, significant coverage is needed "so that we can actually write a whole article, rather than half a paragraph or a definition of that topic." This is not encyclopedic enough to WP:IAR and keep an article that will never be more useful than a stub with past stints listed.


 * Articles for deletion/Brandon Parrish, del mult sources of sparse coverage

Meets NSPORTS

 * Deletion candiate or NHOOPS rewrite: Mike King (basketball), played in Greek Basket League (Olympia)

WikiProject essay
Articles for deletion/Cray Valley Paper Mills F.C. no consensus: many football project members cite essay for notability, while fewer editors say dont meet GNG
 * Articles for deletion/Dontan PCCM F.C., del: GNG vs. WikiProject essay

JBA

 * Articles for deletion/Jordon Myers - del
 * Articles for deletion/Eddie Denard - del
 * Articles for deletion/Deon Lyle -del
 * Articles for deletion/Marquis Johnson (basketball) - del
 * Articles for deletion/Niles Malone -del
 * Articles for deletion/Isom Butler -del
 * Articles for deletion/Curtis Hollis -del
 * Articles for deletion/Caleal Walker - del
 * Articles for deletion/Brandon Phillips (basketball) - del
 * Articles for deletion/Nate Morris (basketball) - del
 * Articles for deletion/Taylor Kirkham - del
 * Articles for deletion/Harrison Rieger - del
 * Articles for deletion/Kezo Brown - keep

Announcer lists

 * Articles for deletion/List of West Coast Conference Men's Basketball Tournament Finals broadcasters
 * Articles for deletion/List of Pacific-12 Conference Men's Basketball Tournament Finals broadcasters del
 * Articles for deletion/List of Atlantic Sun Men's Basketball Tournament Finals broadcasters del
 * Articles for deletion/List of NFL on Fox commentator pairings del

Notable league, non-notable team
Articles for deletion/Bivouac (basketball) del