User:Bkoenker/sandbox

The approximately one billion-year time period between 1.8 and 0.8 Ga in Earth's history that is characterized by environmental, evolutionary, and lithospheric stability is referred to as the Boring Billion. It has also been termed as “Barren Billion”, “Dullest Time on Earth” and “Earth’s Middle Ages”. In the time leading up to the Boring Billion, Earth experienced multiple widespread glaciations, the origin of prokaryotic life, the introduction of oxygen into the atmosphere with the evolution of cyanobacteria, addition of UV-blocking ozone to the atmosphere, and the oxidizing of iron in the oceans. After the Boring Billion, the atmosphere again underwent rapid change as atmospheric oxygen rose to approximately modern levels, most major animal phyla evolved during the Cambrian explosion, and large animals appeared in the oceans. The Boring Billion was thus termed ‘boring’ due to the fact that unlike the rapidly changing environments present on Earth before and after this time period, it is characterized by climatic stability, low levels of atmospheric oxygen, lack of biological events, and the absence of extreme changes in the atmospheric and oceanic composition. Stability during the Boring Billion may be attributed to a relatively stable supercontinent that was initiated by 1.7 Ga and persisted until breakup around 0.75 Ga. The exact timing and duration of the Boring Billion is not agreed upon and estimates for the beginning and end of the Boring Billion range between 1.8-2.4 Ga for initiation and between 0.5-0.8 Ga for termination. The Boring Billion occurred during the Proterozoic Eon.

During the Boring Billion green and purple photosynthetic bacteria appear to have thrived in an anoxic and sulfidic ocean. This ocean was much less productive than modern ones, would have emanated sulphurous gasses including toxic hydrogen sulphide, and was very limited in nutrients (especially Mo, Fe, N, and P). As the Boring Billion progressed, eukaryotic life evolved from a prokaryotic ancestor within this ocean. By the end of the Boring Billion, the first life had appeared on land. Eukaryotes, specifically a proto-lichen, ended the Boring Billion by causing Earth’s second oxygenation event and the Snowball Earth glaciation that accompanied it.

While the Boring Billion has been termed ‘boring’ due to its relative stability, scientists acknowledge that this name might not accurately describe this time. When plate tectonics, environmental conditions, and steps in the evolution of eukaryotic life are examined, this time period doesn’t appear boring at all. It is also important to note that records of this distant time are sparse, and the apparent stability of this period may be due in part to gaps in the geologic record.

Climatic Stability
Recent scientific studies on the Boring Billion have found little evidence of significant climatic variability during this time period. Different theories have been developed by individual scientists to explain the inferred climatic stability whilst others contribute the lack of evidence to an absence of suitable records. There is currently no generally accepted theory in the scientific community on the cause(s) of the climatic stability during the Boring Billion.

Tectonic Constraints
The evolution of Earth’s biosphere, atmosphere and hydrosphere has long been linked to the supercontinent cycle, which posits that Earth’s continental crust undergoes a quasi-periodic cycle of aggregation and dispersal. The period of the Boring Billion is characterized by the evolution of two different supercontinents: Columbia and Rodinia. The supercontinent Columbia amalgamated between 2.0 to 1.7 Ga and remained as a quasi-integral continental lid until at least 1.3 Ga. Several breakup attempts were unsuccessful. Geological and paleomagnetic evidence suggest that Columbia underwent only minor changes to form the supercontinent Rodinia during the period from 1.1 to 0.9 Ga. Paleogeographic reconstructions suggest that the supercontinent assemblage was located in equatorial and temporal climate zones throughout the intervening time frame; there is little or no evidence for continental fragments in polar latitudes. A consequence of the limited breakup history is the paucity of passive margins during the time period from 1.8 to 0.8 Ga. This stable configuration provides the primary constraint on the environmental stasis that characterizes the oceans, atmosphere, and biosphere. The breakup of Rodinia at ~0.75 Ga is considered the end of Earth’s Boring Billion. It should be noted that numerous reconstructions of Columbia’s paleogeography exist and consensus has yet to be reached.

The relative scarcity of passive margins during the Boring Billion, which are created during times of continental breakup, is proposed to support the presence of a stable continental configuration enabling environmental and climate stability during this time period. However, it is also stated in the literature that in spite of the amalgamation of the supercontinents Columbia and Rodinia, relatively stable climatological conditions during the Boring Billion are consistent with a balance between weathering intensity, mantle temperatures and solar insolation throughout much of this time period.

A mechanism put forward to explain low tectonic variability is related to the temperature of the asthenosphere, which may have been too hot to sustain modern plate tectonics in the early stages of the Earth’s evolution. Instead of vigorous plate recycling at subduction zones, plates were linked together for billions of years until the mantle cooled off enough to further sustain plate motions and the subsequent formation of subduction zones. The onset of this component of plate tectonics may have been aided by the thickening of the crust that, once initiated, caused plate subduction to be anomalously strong. This process occurred around 750 Ma ago, when the crust reached a temperature low enough to initiate and sustain plate tectonics in general and subduction processes in particular.

Cosmic Activity
The absence of glaciation could be linked to the intensity of cosmic ray flux, and it is believed that periods of glaciation may be linked to periods with low cosmic ray flux due fluctuations in solar wind variations. Another possible cause is the rate of star formation in the Milky Way. The reduced rate in star formation may be linked to a decreased amount of glaciations from 1 to 2 Ga.

Absence of Prolonged Glaciations
The Boring Billion as a time period is unique in a sense that it seems to lack any significant periods of prolonged glaciations that can be observed in regular periodicity in other part of the Earth's geologic history.

Some researchers believe, however, that the proposed lack of an ozone layer, as expected during periods of low concentrations of atmospheric oxygen, in combination with lower solar intensity during that time period should have precluded the absence of glaciation without an intense greenhouse effect.

Instead, the absence of a glacial record may be a function of data infidelity rather than a real feature of geologic time. Evidence for this are old glacially cut channels, which were found in the Kimberley district of Western Australia that have been dated to 1.8 Ga.

Additionally, the role and timing of the supercontinent cycle and the breakup of Columbia is yet unclear. Evaluating the evidence of paleo poles and continent location becomes increasingly more difficult as deposits get older as relevant rock units show increasing levels of deformation and fragmentation.

Low Oxygen During the Boring Billion
There is a geologic record of two spikes in oxygen levels on Earth, with one occurring between 2.4 to 2.1 Ga, known as the Great Oxygenation Event (GOE), and the second occurring an approximate 0.8 Ga.

The period of time between these two oxygenations is thought to have been characterized by low levels of atmospheric oxygen (O2). Researchers postulate this widespread anoxia was far greater than the anoxic deep oceans seen today (less than 1% of deep ocean). The cause and extent of the oxidation events and the subsequent billion years in between is subject to active debate. Although it was previously believed that atmospheric oxygen levels increased gradually through this period (step model) new research has suggested that after the Great Oxidation Event - in which O2 levels spiked over 1,000 fold, oxygen levels dropped significantly and remained low (with minor fluctuations) until the second oxidation event 0.8 Ga (Figure 1).

The Lomagundi Excursion Event is considered to be the most prominent carbon isotope event in Earth’s history and can provide evidence for this large increase and subsequent decline in O2. For this event a release of 10 to 20 times the current atmospheric oxygen is predicted based on levels found in the carbonate δ13C record around the time of the GOE. Suggestions in the literature point to a ‘precipitous’ drop after the Lomagundi Excursion. The extent to which the GOE served as a ‘Great’ oxidation event, particularly in regards to marine environments, became a topic of discussion in the scientific community, leading Donald Canfield to develop the idea of a two billion year lag in oxygenation of the oceans. He also proposed that the ocean was characterized high levels of hydrogen sulfide during this time, creating a euxinic environment. His explanation has become known as Canfield Ocean. It is believed that the low and fluctuating oxygen levels that characterized the boring billion effectively stalled evolution of complex life for the extent of the Boring Billion. The hypothesis of a predominantly globally euxinic ocean, with low to no oxygen, supports the theory of stalled evolution of complex animals throughout the Boring billion. Complexity is believed to have evolved at the onset of a second oxygenation event and subsequent oxygenation of the ocean 600-800 Ba.

Canfield Ocean Hypothesis
Main Article: Canfield Ocean

Donald Canfield proposed a hypothesis to explain how life persisted in the ocean despite low levels of oxygen. It is believed that during the Boring Billion, the ocean’s surface contained low levels of oxygen as a byproduct of oxygenic photosynthesis from cyanobacteria. Due to increased oxygen levels in the atmosphere, chemical weathering of the continents oxidized the mineral pyrite and transported sulfate (SO42-) to the oceans. Through this process, the ocean became rich in sulfur, and the ocean became a two layer system, consisting of a surface layer high in oxygen and a bottom layer high in sulfur and low in oxygen. Canfield proposed that at boundary between the two layers, green sulfur bacteria and purple bacteria served to convert the sulfur to hydrogen sulfide (H2S). This process of deep sea sulfide creation led to high amounts of pyrite formation during the boring billion, and allowed for the chemical events regarding the evolution of animals to be clearer(Figure 2).

Johnson Ocean Hypothesis
Like the Canfield Ocean model, the Johnson hypothesis serves as a potential explanation of causal factors for tempered oxygenic production. Their model ultimately claims that sulfide driven anoxic photosynthesis via sulfidic prokaryotes helped sustain a long period of deep ocean anoxia, and more specifically, euxinia. This period ended with the exhaustion of sulfide resources, leading to the coupling of oxygenic production and carbon burial that is characteristic of today’s oceans.

At the first order, Johnson’s take on the Canfield model is to recognize that maintaining the anoxygenic conditions requisite for a billion years would be difficult: As organic matter sinks, it decays and releases oxygen gas, a process which is exacerbated by anoxygenic conditions. It has been hypothesized that an explanation for this discrepancy could by a photosynthesis pathway that does not involve oxygen as a byproduct. A modern example of such a system is best exemplified in parts of the Black Sea.

Further Evidence
Gaps in the evidence from ancient rocks have failed to explain the discrepancy between Earth’s atmospheric and oceanic oxygen levels. By tracing the movement of chromium isotopes from land to ocean, a process that is sensitive to atmospheric oxygen levels, Noah Planavksy (biogeochemist at Yale) found the earliest signs of significant chromium oxidation. This suggests levels of atmospheric oxygen levels to have significantly increased around 800 million years ago. Small amounts of oxygen can convert insoluble chromium, a constituent of the continental crust to a soluble form which is then transported to the ocean and deposited in ironstone. By studying the chromium isotope composition in ancient ironstones, measuring the ratio of heavier 53Cr (which is more sensitive to oxidation) to the lighter 52Cr, researchers can determine ancient oxygen levels. This research revealed very low oxygen levels during the ‘Boring Billion’, which are below 0.1% of present atmospheric levels.

Rather than iron oxidation involving iron (III), pyrite formation (FeS2) involves the uptake of iron (II) during euxinic conditions (Figure 3). A research team from the University of Tasmania, under the geologist Ross Large, measured levels of pyrite in ancient seafloor rocks to show that after the initial burst of oxygen 2.4-2.1 Ga there was a decline in oxygen levels until the second oxidation event 800-600 Ma ago.

The Appearance of the First Eukaryotes
In comparison to the great increase in diversity during the Cambrian explosion, the evolution of life during the Boring Billion was relatively slow. However, this period did see the occurrence of several major events in the history of evolution, specifically the development of eukaryotic cells, the acquisition of mitochondria and chloroplasts, multicellularity and sexual reproduction.

The first eukaryotes originated sometime between 2.3 and 1.1 billion years ago, around the beginning of the Boring Billion. The precise onset of eukaryotes evolution is hard to determine, but evidence for the presence of eukaryotic cells during this period can be found in the fossil record and molecular fossils.

Fossil Evidence
Acritarchs, whose name means ‘uncertain origin’, are tiny, roughly spherical fossils present from before 2 billion years ago and throughout the boring billion that cannot be convincingly assigned to any particular part of the tree of life. One interpretation of acritarchs is that they represent the resting stage, or cysts, of eukaryotic algae. However, since bacteria are also known to cysts and spores, a prokaryote origin can’t be ruled out. It is generally agreed by experts on fossil life that acritarchs from about 1.85 Ga and later represent eukaryotes.

Larger two centimeter, 2.1 billion year old spiral fossils found in a mine in Michigan are grouped into the Grypania, a grouping of spiral fossils previously thought to have arisen 1.4-1.6 billion years ago. Traces of internal detail confirm that the younger Grypania fossils are eukaryotes, but the older spirals lack fine detail and may have been made by filaments of prokaryote cells. The older fossils were possibly also incorrectly dated and have a more accurate age of 1.8-1.9 billion years.

Qingshania, an even larger fossil that appeared 1.7 billion years ago, is the oldest known fossil multicellular eukaryote.

Molecular Fossils
Steranes, the traces of sterols used in construction of the membranes of eukaryotes, have been found in 2.7 billion year old shales, and are evidence that eukaryotes, or at least their metabolic ancestors, were present at that time. While the sterols found in these shales are not made by any known modern bacteria, some bacteria are capable of producing sterols. Therefore, sterane presence is not definite evidence of eukaryotic cells.

Eukaryotic Evolution and Diversification
While the first eukaryotes appeared just before or during the Boring Billion, the diversification and evolution of eukaryotes proceeded slowly. Environmental conditions, especially the presence of toxic sulfide, lack of oxygen in ocean water, lack of key nutrients and trace metals in ocean water, and/or little tectonic activity, contributed to slow eukaryotic evolution. Low oxygen levels in ocean water during the Boring Billion may have kept eukaryotes in low numbers and prevented the evolution of large energy hungry, fast moving animals that evolved at the end of the Boring Billion, though it has been argued that even with very little oxygen, animals could have emerged and persevered. It is also known that diversification of eukaryotes began well before the onset of global oxygenation of the oceans, leading to the conclusion that anoxic conditions could not be the only cause of slow eukaryotic evolution.

The anoxic and euxinic conditions of the period would also have affect the abundance of certain nutrients and trace metals in the environment. Both anoxic and sulfidic conditions lead to decreased solubility of iron, while sulfidic conditions lead to increased precipitation of the trace metal molybdenum. Both of these metals are essential for the utilization of nitrogen, as they are necessary for the enzymes nitrate reductase, which reduced nitrate and nitrite to ammonia, and nitrogenase, which reduces atmospheric nitrogen to nitrate. As such, life in the Proterozoic would have suffered from a lack of nitrogen, a situation which would have competitively favored prokaryotes over eukaryotes and likely negatively affected eukaryotic evolution.

Origin of Mitochondria
Based on phylogenetic and structural evidence it is generally accepted that mitochondria were originally derived from an free-living a-proteobacterium. The bacterium was engulfed by an ancient cell, likely an Archaea, entering into an endosymbiotic relationship with its new host.

Most models have explained the origin of the endosymbiosis in terms of the advantage gained by the host cell due to the greater energy production available through aerobic respiration (32 net ATP vs. 2 net for glycolysis). However, this hypothesis has several limitations. No known organism exports ATP to its environment, making it unlikely that a bacterium would begin doing so to its host. In addition, some eukaryotes possess mitochondria derived organelles called hydrogenosomes which perform a type of anaerobic respiration, suggesting an adaptation to an anoxic environment .An alternative explanation known as the Hydrogen Hypothesis suggests that the unique conditions of the Canfield Ocean may have exerted a positive selective pressure on mitochondria for reasons unrelated to aerobic respiration. According to the Hydrogen Hypothesis, the original endosymbiotic event was between a hydrogen producing bacterium and a hydrogen consuming archaea. This symbiosis would have been advantageous in the anoxic conditions in the deeper reaches of the oceans at that time and would explain the widespread phylogenetic distribution of anaerobic respiration genes among eukaryotes.

Cellular Features
The development of advanced cytoskeletons and loss of the rigid bacterial cell wall allowed early eukaryotic cells to change shape. Cell polarity, which allows cells to send a molecular message to one side of the cell but not the other and to interact with nearby cells, also evolved. Between 1.9 and 0.75 Ga, a major diversification of eukaryotes occurred at the supergroup level, with key biological innovations such as cell differentiation, sexual reproduction, and eukaryotic photosynthesis separating eukaryotes into animals, algae, and fungi. (evidence?)