User:Bobthefish2/D

I've decided to file a Wikiquette on User:Phoenix7777.

To keep it short, we both edit in a Chinese-Japanese territorial dispute page (Senkaku Islands and Senkaku Islands dispute). On a recent issue regarding a NPOV violation complaint I raised, I find User:Phoenix7777's behaviour to be unacceptable and disruptive. Since he is still a relatively new user, I believe a Wikiquette is a good place to start, despite the fact the he was already reprimanded for edit-warring in a previous ANI.

For more background about the NPOV matter, see the thread we started in the NPOV noticeboard.


 * - To start out, Phoenix7777 and another user User:Qwyrxian got the article Senkaku Islands dispute locked through edit-warring over a citation added by Phoenix. In response, Phoenix accused him in the talk page that Qwyrxian's actions "impairs his reputation" and that he was abusing some hypothetical privileges. I believe Qwyrxian was actually trying to do BRD, which Phoenix did not accept.


 * - Later in the dispute, I was accused of not responding to a post. Phoenix said I'd be construed as a liar if I didn't respond. He also implied I was a "loser of the discussion" and that I didn't "deserve any tolerance".
 * - Implied I was a pro-Chinese editor (I was the only regular Chinese editor) when I was simply raising an NPOV issue
 * - Accused Qwyrxian of short-sightedness and questionable reading comprehension ability. Also labelled him as a "Chinese editor's spokesperson". The "Chinese editor" was no doubt myself, since again, I was the only Chinese editor who was regularly involved


 * - Labelled my deletion of POV materials to be "disruptive editing"


 * - Just recently, he played a part in forcing an admin to lock the other Senkaku Islands page as well. While he chastised others of edit-warring, he also participated in it. Bobthefish2 (talk) 04:48, 3 March 2011 (UTC)