User:Bonobo12345/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Talk:Kombucha

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I am interested in the biochemistry aspect of making kombucha and it is related to other Chem 300 class activities.

Evaluate the article
Everything in the article is relevant to the topic. I would say the last part of other uses was a little distracting but it was placed below so that's fine. The section on health affects has quoted papers from 2003 and 2009 which may be out of date in terms of medical aspects since there are always more insightful research that has been done in recent years.

The tone of the article is neutral and has touched upon both the harmful and potential good effects of komboucha. The rest of the information is presented in a factual manner.

In general, the sources that are chosen are from journals and the rest of which that aren't are used to present information regarding the history of the product which might not be mentioned in journals. There are certain tags that seem out of the blue which have been debated about in the talk page. One of them which is Jilly Juice which is tagged in the see other section but a connection is not mentioned.

There is a solid foundation to this page but there are still many errors and the citations and tags are not all accurate making this a C class article. It is of low importance on wiki projects.