User:Born2cycle/RMlog

2019 Participations
Note: A green or  means my !vote was consistent with ultimate outcome, a red means it wasn't. Uncolored means it's still open or I haven't updated it yet.


 * 1) Charlevoix tourist train → Train de Charlevoix, Talk:Train_de_Charlevoix,
 * 2) Date format by country → All-numeric date format by country, Talk:Date_format_by_country, Oppose
 * 3) Ghost World (film) → Ghost World, Talk:Ghost_World_(film), Support
 * 4) PVRIS → Pvris, Talk:PVRIS, Oppose
 * 5) Alcatraz Citadel → Fort Alcatraz, Talk:Alcatraz_Citadel, Support
 * 6) M. J. Cole → MJ Cole, Talk:MJ_Cole,
 * 7) Look Now (album) → Look Now, Talk:Look_Now_(album), Support
 * 8) Gigi → Gigi (novella), Talk:Gigi, Oppose
 * 9) *Support moving Gigi (1958 film) to Gigi
 * 10) Andrew Yang (entrepreneur) → Andrew Yang, {Talk:Andrew_Yang,
 * 11) Enduro → Enduro (motorcycle sport), Talk:Enduro,
 * 12) Climate change → Climate change (historical), Talk:Climate_change,
 * 13) Al Manara Stadium → Rafic El-Hariri Stadium, Talk:Rafic_El-Hariri_Stadium,
 * 19:08, 1 March 2019 (UTC), March (disambiguation) → March, Talk:March_(disambiguation), 00:13, 2 March 2019 (UTC),
 * 18:17, 16 February 2019 (UTC) BlackBerry Messenger → BBM (software) Talk:BlackBerry_Messenger, 21:12, 1 March 2019 (UTC), nom
 * 06:14, 14 February 2019 (UTC)- Celtic polytheism → Celtic paganism Talk:Celtic_polytheism, 2:18, 1 March 2019 (UTC), Support alternative
 * 1) *Participated in discussions repeatedly trying to help find consensus for a particular new title as current and proposed appear to be opposed by consensus.
 * 16:11, 15 February 2019 (UTC) Dreamland (upcoming film) → ?, Talk:Dreamland_(upcoming_film),
 * 1) *Alternative I proposed is a slight variant, omitting the word "upcoming" from the disambiguation, which prevailed. Dreamland (Miles Joris-Peyrafitte film) and Dreamland (Nicholas Jarecki film).
 * 2) *Closing reads like a super vote.
 * 3) *I'm with consensus on using director's name to disambiguate two current (same year) films with same title, but oppose retaining "upcoming" in disambiguation.
 * 20:03, 23 February 2019 (UTC), Dangerous goods → Hazardous materials, Talk:Dangerous_goods, Support
 * 22:53, 21 February 2019 (UTC), State Farm Arena (Atlanta) → State Farm Arena, Talk:State_Farm_Arena,
 * 1) *Unanimous decision
 * 2) Crédit Mobilier of America scandal → Crédit Mobilier scandal Talk:Crédit_Mobilier_of_America_scandal,
 * 3) 2012 Aurora shooting → 2012 Aurora, Colorado shooting Talk:2012_Aurora_shooting,
 * 4) multi-move Talk:Love_Thy_Neighbor_(TV_series), Support 3 out of 4
 * 5) David Leitch (director) → David Leitch, Talk:David_Leitch_(director),
 * 6) * Converted to multi to include dab page explicitly, which was implied
 * 7) Peshtigo Fire → Peshtigo fire  Talk:Peshtigo_fire
 * 8) 1993 Aurora shooting → 1993 Aurora, Colorado shooting Talk:1993_Aurora_shooting
 * 9) Kelly Overton (actress) → Kelly Overton, Talk:Kelly_Overton,
 * 10) Lisp (programming language) → Lisp (programming language family), Talk:Lisp_(programming_language),
 * 11) * Nom withdrew proposal.
 * 12) Aurora, Illinois shooting → 2019 Aurora, Illinois shooting, Talk:Aurora,_Illinois_shooting,
 * 13) * Proposed alt at: Talk:Aurora,_Illinois_shooting
 * 14) National Police Corps → National Police Corps (Spain), Talk:National_Police_Corps,
 * 15) Columbine → Columbine (disambiguation), Talk:Columbine,
 * 16) *Considerable support, but not enough.
 * 17) POP TV → Pop TV, Talk:Pop_TV,
 * 18) *Initially opposed, but was persuaded by evidence to support
 * 19) Sarah Huckabee Sanders → Sarah Sanders, Talk:Sarah_Sanders,
 * 12:47, 15 February 2019 (UTC) The Princess Bride → The Princess Bride (novel), Talk:The_Princess_Bride_(novel),
 * 19:27, 13 February 2019 (UTC) Joaquín "El Chapo" Guzmán → El Chapo, Talk:Joaquín_"El_Chapo"_Guzmán,
 * 1) *Some support, but much stronger opposition.
 * 2) Automobile safety → Automotive safety, Talk:Automotive_safety,
 * 3) Brett Anderson → Brett Anderson (English musician), Talk:Brett_Anderson,
 * 4) List of films featuring insects → List of films featuring anthropomorphic insects, Talk:List_of_films_featuring_insects,
 * 5) *Last of a few participants; likely swayed consensus determination outcome
 * 6) Saturday Night (Is the Loneliest Night of the Week) → Saturday Night (Is the Loneliest Night in the Week), Talk:Saturday_Night_(Is_the_Loneliest_Night_of_the_Week),
 * 7) *Only participant.
 * 8) You (film) → You (2009 film), Talk:You_(2009_film),
 * 9) *A lonely oppose among a swarm of support. Note to self: Strong sign that consensus opposes partial disambiguations, at least in film titles.
 * 10) Democratic Action Party (disambiguation) → Democratic Action Party, Talk:Democratic_Action_Party_(disambiguation),
 * 11) Jason Mitchell (actor) → Jason Mitchell, Talk:Jason_Mitchell,
 * 12) Marina and the Diamonds → Marina Diamandis, Talk:Marina_and_the_Diamonds,
 * 13) *I did propose an alternative,Marina (Welsh singer), but I was late to the discussion and it did not gain traction.
 * 14) Sepp family (publishing) → Sepp family, Talk:Sepp_publishing_family,
 * 15) *Although the nom and I supported Sepp family, the (super vote?) closer went with IIO's minority suggestion of Sepp publishing family, so I'm going with brown (combo of green and red) here.
 * 16) Biafran War → Nigerian Civil War, Talk:Nigerian_Civil_War,
 * 17) Template:Stars of Andromeda → Template:Constellation of Andromeda, etc. (huge multi-move), Template_talk:Andromeda_(constellation),
 * 18) Client (prostitution) → John (prostitution), Talk:Client_(prostitution),
 * 19) *In retrospect, I should have opposed. John is too slangy.
 * 20) TVA → TVA (disambiguation) (etc.), Talk:TVA,
 * 21) Common chimpanzee → Chimpanzee, Talk:Chimpanzee,
 * 22) German mediatization → German mediatisation, Talk:German_mediatisation,
 * 23) *Example of supporting article's original British English variation per ENGVAR.
 * 24) Eyes Open (album) → Eyes Open, Talk:Eyes_Open,
 * 25) Positron emission tomography–magnetic resonance imaging → PET-MR, Talk:PET-MRI,
 * 26) Franc Miklošič → Franz Miklosich, Talk:Franz_Miklosich,
 * 27) Ha Dabateer → Hada Bateer, Talk:Ha_Dabateer,
 * 28) Prussian Blue → Prussian Blue (duo), Talk:Prussian_Blue_(duo),
 * 29) SDCCU Stadium → San Diego Stadium, Talk:SDCCU_Stadium.
 * 30) John Nesbitt (announcer) → John Nesbitt, Talk:John_Nesbitt,
 * 31) Armagnac (brandy) → Armagnac, Talk:Armagnac,
 * 32) Bethungra, New South Wales → Bethungra, Junee Shire, Talk:Bethungra,_New_South_Wales,
 * 33) Black Pink → Blackpink, Talk:Blackpink,
 * 34) Perry → Perry (drink), Talk:Perry,
 * 35) My Friend Irma (entertainment property) → My Friend Irma, Talk:My_Friend_Irma,
 * 36) Yup'ik → Yup'ik people, Talk:Yup%27ik,
 * 37) Lithium (medication) → Lithium as medication (etc., massive multi-move), Talk:Lithium_(medication),
 * 38) Jewish deicide → Jewish deicide allegation, Talk:Jewish_deicide,
 * 39) Okkupert → Occupied, Talk:Occupied,
 * 40) Cardross, Argyll → Cardross, Talk:Cardross,
 * 41) St Ishmaels (Pembrokeshire) → St Ishmael's, Talk:St_Ishmaels,
 * 42) Sounds of Silence (documentary) → Sounds of Silence (2006 film), Talk:Sounds_of_Silence_(2006_film),
 * 43) List of Attack on Titan episodes → Attack on Titan (TV series), Talk:Attack_on_Titan_(TV_series),
 * 44) Abbey Hill, Milton Keynes → Abbey Hill, Talk:Abbey_Hill,
 * 45) Golden Ring → Golden Ring of Russia, Talk:Golden_Ring_of_Russia,
 * 46) *Sole opposing, but only three participants.
 * 47) Radisson Hotel Group → Rezidor Hotel Group, Talk:Rezidor_Hotel_Group,
 * 48) Louise Sand → Loui Sand, Talk:Loui_Sand,
 * 49) Northumbrian dialect (Old English) → Northumbrian Old English, Talk:Northumbrian_Old_English,
 * 50) Vinzan → Vinjhan, Talk:Vinjhan,
 * 51) Herne Bay, Kent → Herne Bay, Talk:Herne_Bay,
 * 52) Farlow, Shropshire → Farlow, Talk:Farlow,_Shropshire,
 * 53) Natalia Keery-Fisher → Teddy Sinclair, Talk:Teddy_Sinclair,
 * 54) Julián Castro → Julián Castro (disambiguation), Talk:Julian_Castro,
 * 55) Université catholique de Louvain → University of Louvain, Talk:Université_catholique_de_Louvain,
 * 56) Sakastan → Sakastan (Sasanian Province), Talk:Sakastan_(Sasanian_province),
 * 57) Suspenders → ?, Talk:Suspenders,
 * 58) Dow Jones & Company → Dow Jones, Talk:Dow_Jones_%26_Company,
 * 59) NOTE: on January 22

2019 Closes
NOTE: closes are unchallenged in any way unless noted otherwise in .
 * 1) Template:Infobox settlement → ?, Template_talk:Infobox_settlement, not moved
 * 2) Anthony Browne (UK politics) → ?, Talk:Anthony_Browne_(lobbyist), Move to Anthony Browne (lobbyist)
 * 3) Skin (2018 film) → ?, Talk:Skin_(2018_feature_film), Moved
 * 4) *As I noted in the close this was a good solution to an unusual situation but leaving this where it was and a hatnote to the short film with the same name from the same year and director, as one participant noted, would have worked too.
 * 5) Special (Garbage song) → Special (song), Talk:Special_(song), Moved
 * 6) French Mandate for Syria and the Lebanon → Mandate for Syria and the Lebanon (and two more), Talk:Mandate_for_Syria_and_the_Lebanon, moved
 * 7) *Only three participants including nom but all agree on the moves or are neutral with one preferring no parenthetical on the two with legal instrument parenthetical disambiguation. Since no one objected to that preference, and in fact the nom offered to make another proposal to drop those indicating nom was good with it too, I went ahead and moved accordingly (well, submitted tech requests to move them).
 * 8) Fayoum SC → Faiyum SC (etc.; multi-move); Talk:Faiyum_SC, Consensus to move
 * 9) 9 to 5 (film) → Nine to Five (film)  Talk:9_to_5_(film), Consensus to not move.
 * 10) MMR vaccine and autism → ? Talk:MMR_vaccine_and_autism
 * 11) *Proposal with wide open destination, referring to discussion previous to the RM and requested a close, appeared to be classic situation of consensus for a title change but no consensus on which particular new title to use. I did my best to choose best title per WP:THREEOUTCOMES based on table that showed one particular title (with "myth" − MMR–autism myth) had most support and left note in closing statement asking to be notified on my talk page if any issues, and moved the article accordingly. Unfortunately I inadvertently added a period to the title when I renamed and used a hyphen instead of an en-dash, and used the exact title listed in the discussion which was missing a word ("vaccine"). These issues were brought to my attention   and I responded as follows:
 * 12) **fixed the period error
 * 13) **verified the en-dash convention and fixed that too (per MOS:DASH - file under: learn something every day)
 * 14) **suggested we wait a day to see if we had consensus on the addition of "vaccine" to the title, leaving the title at MMR–autism myth (understanding a likely move to MMR vaccine–autism myth in a day, pending some feedback/confirmation from others).
 * 15) *Well, an INVOLVED admin was not happy with that, and, without first discussing with me on my talk page,, , closed the discussion and even filed an ANI, returning the article to MMR vaccine and autism.
 * 16) *The discussion continues as of March 1 with little progress.
 * 17) Thiomersal and vaccines → Thimerosal controversy  Talk:Thiomersal_and_vaccines, consensus to not move
 * 18) The Independent Group → The Independent Group (United Kingdom)  Talk:The_Independent_Group, Not moved (no consensus either way).
 * 19) Talk:Park_Street_station_(MBTA)
 * 20) * I closed as moved, then new evidence was presented, I was, I did revert and relist, the new evidence prevailed (and rightfully so, IMHO), and ultimately the article was not moved after all. No drama.
 * 21) The Defender (novel) → The Defender (Kalashnikoff novel), Talk:The_Defender_(Kalashnikoff_novel), Consensus to move (unanimous)
 * 22) Live action → Live-action, Talk:Live_action, Not moved
 * 23) Winter sport → List of winter sports, Talk:Winter_sports, Found consensus to move to counter-proposed Winter sports
 * 24) 2015 Japanese military legislation → Legislation for Peace and Security, Talk:2015_Japanese_military_legislation, Consensus is not moved
 * 25) SuperXclusivo → La Comay, Talk:SuperXclusivo, not moved
 * 26) Murthy (surname) → Murthy, Talk:Murthy, moved
 * 27) 2015 Japanese military legislation → Legislation for Peace and Security, Talk:2015_Japanese_military_legislation, Not moved
 * 28) Waste tires → Tire recycling in the United States, Talk:Tire_recycling_in_the_United_States, Moved
 * 29) Homo sapiens → Anatomically modern human, Talk:Homo_sapiens, Not moved
 * 30) Lawas → Lawas District, Talk:Lawas, Not moved
 * 31) Vladimirs Buzajevs → Vladimir Buzayev, Talk:Vladimir_Buzayev, Moved
 * 32) What Men Want → What Men Want (1930 film), Talk:What_Men_Want_(1930_film), Moved
 * 33) Wikipedia:WikiProject Pornography → Wikipedia:WikiProject Erotica and Pornography, Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Pornography, Not moved
 * 34) List of actors nominated for Academy Awards for foreign language performances → List of actors nominated for Academy Awards for non-English performances, Talk:List_of_actors_nominated_for_Academy_Awards_for_non-English_performances, Moved
 * 35) Template:Pornography → Template:Erotica and Pornography, Template_talk:Pornography, Not moved
 * 36) Mustafabad, Haryana → Saraswati Nagar, Talk:Saraswati_Nagar, Moved
 * 37) Hephthalite Empire → Hephthalites, Talk:Hephthalites, Moved
 * 38) Thor (Marvel Cinematic Universe) → Thor (Marvel Cinematic Universe character), Talk:Thor_(Marvel_Cinematic_Universe), Not moved
 * 39) John Grogan (journalist) → John Grogan, Talk:John_Grogan, Moved
 * 40) Timor-Leste national football team → East Timor national football team, Talk:Timor-Leste_national_football_team, Not moved
 * 41) Huron University College → Huron University, Talk:Huron_University_College, 'Reverted to original name
 * 42) *From closing statement: "This is confusing since the article was moved before the original RM was closed, then the RM was closed and then reopened subsequent to the move. In any case, there is no consensus for the recent move, so it needs to be reverted."
 * 43) 2018 Independence Cup → ?, Talk:2017–18_Independence_Cup_(Bangladesh), Not moved
 * 44) *A subsequent proposal which I did not close nor participate in, based on a suggestion I made in my close, did succeed. See Talk:2017–18_Independence_Cup_(Bangladesh).
 * 45) She → She (pronoun), Talk:She_(pronoun), Moved
 * 46) Who Gets the Dog? (film) → Who Gets the Dog? (2016 film), etc. (multi-move), Talk:Who_Gets_the_Dog%3F_(2016_film), Moved four articles
 * 47) Julian Castro → Julián Castro (American politician), Talk:Julian_Castro, not moved
 * 48) Catherine Hill → Catherine Hill (Brunnerton woman), Talk:Catherine_Hill, not moved
 * 49) Entry of women to Sabarimala Ayyappa Temple → Entry of women to Sabarimala, Talk:Entry_of_women_to_Sabarimala, moved

BOLD (no RM discussion) moves
''NOTE: I very rarely make a move without an RM discussion. Only if I'm as certain as reasonably possible that the move is not potentially controversial will I do so''
 * 1) This is L. Inc. → L. Inc., I reverted move that was made while an RM was in progress.
 * RM: Talk:L._Inc. (result of which was to stay at L. Inc.; I did not participate in discussion or closing).
 * 1) Kelly Overton (animal rights activist)→ Kelly Overton (activist), Per side discussion at Talk:Kelly_Overton_(actress)
 * 2) *Only person with this name that is an activist of any kind, so specifying type of activist in disambiguation is superfluous per widespread conventions supported by longstanding community consensus.

DiDi (September, 2018)
My close of DiDi (company) → Didi Chuxing (moved to DiDi) was unilaterally reverted (no discussion, no MR), I was accused of super-voting, and, a few days later, the discussion was closed by an admin almost identically, with the same move I had decided to make.


 * Original move to DiDi after close:
 * My original reasoning:
 * Revert of the move:
 * Revert reasoning:
 * Move after re-close:
 * Re-close reasoning:

Iznik pottery (2017)
Note: I believe I've been claiming that none of my closes have been challenged at MR. However, I had forgotten this one went to MR. It was not overturned, so I can still safely say no close of mine has ever been taken to MR and overturned. İznik pottery → Iznik pottery Talk:Iznik_pottery
 * After multiple editors requested I revert my close finding consensus to move (see: User_talk:Born2cycle/Archive_13), I noted all of the requesters were either involved and opposed the proposal, or had a history of disagreeing with me. I was willing to revert if one objective editor requested it, but no such objective editor surfaced. So, it was taken to WP:MR which resulted in no consensus to overturn: Move_review/Log/2017_May.