User:BozMo/WMC-on-BLPs

Discussion by invitation only
This discussion is for invited parties only. Comments by other people are not invited and will be removed At present people who have been invited are: BozMo

WMC and BLPs
A number of issues about WMC's behaviour on BLPs have been raised which merit some more discussion to see if there is room for some agreed changes. These issues include:


 * 1) Whether WMC has relationships with subjects of BLPs which might preclude him editing them
 * 2) Whether WMC's editing and talk page style is less suitable for BLPs where many issues are soft and subjective
 * 3) Whether WMC has a tendency to give undue weight to less impressive aspects of the lifes of Global Warming sceptics
 * 4) Whether attention should be paid to external commentary on his edits of BLPs
 * 5) Whether WMC has too much tendency to rely on his own judgements rather than the evidence of reliable sources especially ref BLPs where we need to be seen to be clean.