User:BrenChare/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Basque Country (autonomous community)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
The Basque Country is an interesting Autonomous region that has so much history and has been around for so long. This article, I feel, deserves to be given proper information and credit to these people.

Evaluate the article
While the Lead Section does give a good introduction to the article, it only gives a brief on its history but lacks a brief on other sections in the article such as its geography and politics. The lead section is also overly concise, I feel it still lacks key information. However, It doesn't state information that isn't mentioned in other sections

The Demographics section is shorter than the languages section, which doesn't make sense, these sections also don't totally align. There are other misalignments between different sections such as the inclusion and differences from it's politics, history, and present day politics, lacking a gist of what its main form of political power is. There is also no mention or little mention of all locations they are present in and their agreements there.

The article seems to be neutral and does not weigh heavily to a certain idea. It doesn't bring a lot of speaking from the group or specific groups, but it doesn't attempt to make the reader feel a certain way about a certain topic.

The article looks appealing; the images are good quality and placed in an effective manner, the text is not too jumbled and is split up well and broken up into sections efficiently. While it gives a lot of imagery to important pieces of architecture and influential buildings, some images aren't efficiently talked about to have been provided in the article. More images of what the towns and all areas look like would add value to the article.

It's hard to see how the article is pulling from reliable sources as they're in Spanish, but the articles have a lot of information that I know is included in the article. There's no copyright and there are a variety of articles that adds to the context of the topic and with no bias that would cause assumptions to the article.

The talk page discussions are very minimal and could have a lot more added to it, they are very bias discussions and more in favor of other countries This topic relates to autonomous regions wikiproject. The talk about an autonomous country and border conflicts relates to our talks about independence and American values of having pride of our own country.

My overall impressions of the article is that it lacks a lot of information that I feel would add to who lives there, Its strengths are that it holds information on where it came from and the status of the region now. It can be improved with the addition of more connected sections and the additions of all places that the people live in now and why. The article is underdeveloped and could have a lot of edits to add to context and key information of the Basque country.