User:ButterflyGirl135/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Talk:Asgardians (Marvel Comics)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Comics are an interesting topic to me in general, and this article had some blatant issues which make it good for this article evaluation. Things like a clearly missing image of Thor due to copyrights.

Evaluate the article
There is a decent introduction about the Asgardians in the Marvel Comics universe. There is a link to "Demons" that does not lead to any article or source. Same thing with the listed character of "Frey". The "Talk" page also has links that do not go anywhere or websites that are removed. The article is written decently but there is a lack of clarity and there are many claims that do not have a source. The "Talk" section also backs this up as one of the authors claims that some of the information is not backed up by anything but is from their own interpretation. The order the information is presented in is also slightly odd, as there does not seem to be too much of a reason or purpose for the order.

The article does not have any media, which in this case, is important as visual demonstrations could greatly enhance this article. There is however interesting and relevant points in this article that, after editing and revision, add to the article. Going back to the citations in the article, there are various in-text citations that need to actually have a source attached to them. Subheadings such as "Reception" may not need to exist or may need to be delved into deeper, as there is only one brief, fairly relevant sentence under that section.