User:CA387/Category Proposal

After thinking about the category guidelines for WP:MUSICIANS, they seem rather inefficient: the only way I could see not adding musicians to their parent category as sensible would be if Wikipedia automatically listed members of all subcategories. And as far as a page with all Americans listed, what about Category:Living people? Goes to show you how the category thing is superior to list pages. Not to mention the fact that the list pages themselves can't even conform to a standard, as some are by date (oboists, violinists), others by alphabetical order (List of cellists). Or problem of, say, an ethnically Scottish violinist that lives in London. What I propose is hierarchy somewhat like this, in which a member would be added into a specific category and all parent categories:
 * Musicians
 * Music educators
 * Musicians by genre
 * Musicians by nationality
 * Musicians by instrument
 * (Specific Instrumentalist)s
 * SIs by nationality
 * SIs by genre
 * SIs by profession
 * SI teachers
 * SI performers
 * SI soloists
 * SI orchestral players
 * SI band members
 * SI chamber musicians