User:CSTKing/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
C. S. Lewis

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I have recently been researching C. S. Lewis and his writing history and am particularly interested in his professional life as professor and writer. The article has been evaluated as needing content, and the contributors are discussing several elements that need expansion or clarification.

Evaluate the article
The article has a strong lead with strong biographical and professional information. The first sentence omits his role as professor but emphasizes his writing. The lead does provide some information about the roles he held, but it omits that the article will address relationships.

The article states that C. S. Lewis published two books of poetry; however, it presents the works without noting that they were poorly received and that he failed as a poet.

The content is current and relevant; however, it seems incomplete, as it does not relay influences and friendships with other notable writers beyond the Inklings.

It is neutral, although the writers appear to still be arguing about his nationality and how that should be relayed in the biographical narrative.

A few facts need additional citations. The article contains images and they are captioned.

Yes, the article is rated as needing work. I have put a comment into the page to ask about including work that was not "published" but that is relevant.