User:Caffeinatedmicrobe/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Mangrove crab

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose it because it is our group's page for our project it matters because crabs are important drivers of biogeochemical activity. Initial impression is it was short and not in depth.

Evaluate the article
Lead: Doesn't give a summary of the article just is a short paragraph about the crabs.

Content: There is a lot of detail missing from the page and it feels quite general.

Tone: feels a bit informal but is otherwise neutral.

Sources: the sources seem good but the article is just lacking the full range of information found in the sources.

Organization: there are not enough sections as the page is brief.

Talk page: the only thing on the page is what I added it was rated low and needs work.

Overall: what is present is good work but it doesn't capture the full extent of the topic and needs many more sources and topics included in the article.