User:CaitlynRCooper/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Low-key Photography

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose the article because I am interested in photography. The article explains the technique behind low-key lighting and the history of it's use. My first impression of the article is that it includes in-depth information on the topic and the information is relevant.

Evaluate the article
Lead

The lead includes an introductory sentence to the article. The sentence includes relevant information about the article. The lead does not include irrelevant information and is concise.

Content

The content in the article is on topic and relevant. The content is up to date and does not appear to be missing important information. Topic does not include one of Wikipedia's equity gap topics.

Tone and Balance

The Wikipedia article is written with neutrality in mind. There are no claims that are heavily biased or misrepresent the information. The article does not try to persuade the reader.

Sources

The article correctly links relevant topics and sources important information. The sources are up to date and thorough. The sources link include a variety of different medias, including journals, books, and web-content. After clicking through links, a few appear to have broken as they are from 2017.

Organization

The article is broken down into several sections. Each of the sections is clear and easy to read and understand. The organization of the article makes it easy to find information.

Images

The article includes several images describing low-key photography. The images are relevant and enhance the article by being used as great visual examples. The images are captioned correctly and laid out in a visually appealing way.

Talk Page

The talk page includes discussions of how to make the Wikipedia article more concise and accurate. The most recent discussion includes how to correctly caption one of the images being used as an example. The article is apart of two WikiProjects, WikiProjects Visual Arts and WikiProjects Photography.

Overall impressions

The article is named a Good Article. The articles strengths is within it's organization of the information and it's use of examples to describe what low-key photography looks like. The article can be improved by including more information and examples of low-key photography that does not include just using body paint as a technique. The article is well-developed.