User:CatherineMLindsay/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title
 * We Are the Radical Monarchs
 * Article Evaluation
 * I would like to add information about the Radical Monarchs and their founders. Also, this article would benefit from historical context as well as a detailed history of the Girls Scouts organization. (Would it make more sense to add a new, separate page for the Radical Monarchs?)
 * Sources
 * RE: the information provided: this article is well-sourced.
 * <<< If the article is "well-sourced" and does not appear to suffer from a serious content gap, then I suggest to choose another article. In your evaluation, what important information do you think was missing in this article? Why do you think adding information about the Radical Monarchs and their founders will help the world understand intersectional inequalities?
 * RE: the information provided: this article is well-sourced.
 * <<< If the article is "well-sourced" and does not appear to suffer from a serious content gap, then I suggest to choose another article. In your evaluation, what important information do you think was missing in this article? Why do you think adding information about the Radical Monarchs and their founders will help the world understand intersectional inequalities?

Option 2

 * Article title
 * A Woman's Place (bookstore)
 * Article Evaluation
 * This article would benefit from historical context. In addition, I would like to locate biographical information for the bookstore's founders.
 * Sources
 * This article is well-sourced RE: the information published.
 * <<< Again, if this article is "well-sourced," why do you think it would benefit from having some historical context? Why do you think biographical information for the bookstore's founders may improve the quality of this article?
 * This article is well-sourced RE: the information published.
 * <<< Again, if this article is "well-sourced," why do you think it would benefit from having some historical context? Why do you think biographical information for the bookstore's founders may improve the quality of this article?

Option 3

 * Article title
 * Rose Marie Muraro
 * Article Evaluation
 * This article needs expansion. For example, Muraro's biography can be more detailed. Also, I would like to add information about her "controversial" books and ideas.
 * Sources
 * Clearly, this article requires deep digging for sources as there are very few citations. Locating an English translation of Muraro's memoir would be of great starting point, though, not an ideal source.
 * <<< I agree; this article seems to be lacking everything, from her biographical information to some of the concepts and theories advanced in her writing. Compared to the other two articles, I say this one suffers the most from information deficiency. It is important to also ask how her works may be relevant for thinking about gender, welfare and poverty.
 * Clearly, this article requires deep digging for sources as there are very few citations. Locating an English translation of Muraro's memoir would be of great starting point, though, not an ideal source.
 * <<< I agree; this article seems to be lacking everything, from her biographical information to some of the concepts and theories advanced in her writing. Compared to the other two articles, I say this one suffers the most from information deficiency. It is important to also ask how her works may be relevant for thinking about gender, welfare and poverty.

Option 4

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources

Option 5

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources