User:Cehceh27/sandbox

Article Evaluation for the "Book of Wei"

This article is rated in the "Stub" class which isn't considered as reliable or doesn't provide a complete overview of the topic.

One major problem is the fact that there is only one source used to support the information given.

The introductory text could be more complete and provide a much better overview of what is going to be discussed.

The tone of the text is written in a judgemental way as to not convey an impartial approach.

The tense used is not consistently past tense as it should be.

The concluding paragraph could not truly be considered a solid conclusion as it does not give the reader any kind of summary or closure.

Another text is mentioned without any reasoning as to why.

Considering the information available on the Wei Dynasty, there appears to be much lacking in terms of giving an overall context.

There are numerous claims made in the article that are not given citations.

This article is part of the WikiProject China and the goal is to improve articles like this so at least there is a realization that there needs to be improvement.

Cehceh27 (talk) 18:49, 7 November 2017 (UTC)Cehceh27