User:Chindian1992/sandbox

Article Evaluation:

Article: "Alternative Energy"

Content: Everything in this article seems to be accurate to the title. The article consists of different types of alternative energy source, each energy source were described and evaluated. Advantaged and disadvantages of alternative energy were also listed. I would like to see statistics on the production of alternative energy vs fossil fuels added to this article.

Tone: Although this article clearly is bias towards the use of alternative energy compared to fossil fuel, I agree that renewable energy/ alternative energy is the best choice of fuel.

Sources: sources that were utilized in this article helps reinforce and educate the alternative energies being described in this article.

Talk: This is article is a part of two wiki projects called "Energy" and "Environment. There is a talk topic which states that the article is stating renewable energy as alternative and fission as conventional is incorrect, I highly agree with this talk due to renewable energy not being so much as an alternative any more, and coal is not as conventional today.

Article Selection:

Article #1: "Biodegradable Plastic"

Critique: This article has a very good topic, but the content needs plenty of cleaning up. In the start of the article it states that two basic classes exists, throughout the article these two classes were never distinguished from each other.

Tone: This is written to promote biodegradable plastic, but provides disadvantages and advantages. The article does not heavily push audiences towards biodegradable plastics. Although there are many disadvantages that are not listed, for example these plastics could be harmful when burnt.

Sources: This article has little to no amount of citations. Many information and statistics were written down with no citation to reinforce these information.

Talk: There are many talks on how the article could use plenty of citations, also people are stating that this article could be a little bias with stating disadvantages information.

Article#2: "Solar Car"

Critique: The article seems to have limited information on solar cars.

Tone: This was an informative article on specifically solar cars.

Sources: The sources were available but information was limited to specific topics.

Talk: Very little to no amount of conversations and arguments were made.

Article #3: "Alternative Energy"

Content: Everything in this article seems to be accurate to the title. The article consists of different types of alternative energy source, each energy source were described and evaluated. Advantaged and disadvantages of alternative energy were also listed. I would like to see statistics on the production of alternative energy vs fossil fuels added to this article.

Tone: Although this article clearly is bias towards the use of alternative energy compared to fossil fuel, I agree that renewable energy/ alternative energy is the best choice of fuel.

Sources: sources that were utilized in this article helps reinforce and educate the alternative energies being described in this article.

Talk: This is article is a part of two wiki projects called "Energy" and "Environment. There is a talk topic which states that the article is stating renewable energy as alternative and fission as conventional is incorrect, I highly agree with this talk due to renewable energy not being so much as an alternative any more, and coal is not as conventional today.