User:ClimbingGal/Evaluate an Article

Antillean Creole
Antillean Creole

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
It is the article I will be editing for my project. It matters because it it the language spoken by many people in the Antilles. My preliminary impression was that it was fairly good, but the variety sections are quite short.

Evaluate the article
It has a good lead section, but none of the information in the history section has reference to the place it came from! This is very bad. I also think it could be more balanced by adding more information the the varieties. The tone seems neutral. The article's status is a stub, and now that I've looked at it more in depth, I agree. The strengths are that the article had a good start of information, but a weakness is that much of it isn't cited. There is a variety of references, but not enough for the numerous varieties it covers. There is not much talk happening in the talk page, so I don't think people are actively editing it. ClimbingGal (talk) 03:47, 28 September 2021 (UTC)