User:Coldbrew831/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Percy Jackson & the Olympians

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it was a formative piece of children's literature during my development and because it is currently culturally relevant; a Disney+ series based on the books is coming out this December.

Evaluate the article
I. Lead section: The lead section contains a good overview, but I think it could be a little more detailled, and it contains a glaring grammatical error.

II. Content: The content of the article is generally relevant to the topic, detailled, and comprehensive without containing unnecessary details. However, the plot section skips over some important aspects and includes some unnecessary details.

III. Tone and Balance: The article is balanced well; it does not contain much bias, if any. It includes equal mention of both positive and negative reviews.

IV: Sourcing: There are many sources from a diverse set of reliable authors.

V. Organization and Writing Quality: The organization of the article is good, but the writing quality varies. There are some sections that feel as if they might have been written by middle-school fans of the book. It's easy enough to read, but lacks sophistication and has some questionable word choices.

VI. Images: There are few images in the article. There should be an image of a book cover and/or the main character, not just the logo of the series.

VII. Talk page: The talk page includes discussion of including information about the upcoming TV series, changing the image to the US rather than UK book logo, and adding information about how Riordan used his students as inspritation for the series and his characters' names.

VIII. Overall status: While the writing could be cleaned up and more images included, the article is generally in good shape. B-Class seems a good qualification for this article.